- Carrollton Elementary School reported a higher violent incidents than North Saginaw Charter Academy (101 vs. 30).
- North Saginaw Charter Academy reported a higher out-of-school suspensions than Carrollton Elementary School (40 vs. 0).
- North Saginaw Charter Academy reported a higher chronically absent students than Carrollton Elementary School (323 vs. 297).
- Source Data Limit: 5 metrics are directly comparable between the two schools.
- Source Data Limit: 1 additional metric is reported by only one school.
Attendance
How consistently students are present
North Saginaw Charter Academy reported a higher chronically absent students than Carrollton Elementary School (323 vs. 297).
School Environment
Disciplinary actions from the Civil Rights Data Collection
Carrollton Elementary School reported a higher violent incidents than North Saginaw Charter Academy (101 vs. 30).
Staffing & Support
Counselor and support staff capacity
Carrollton Elementary School reported a higher counselors (full time employee) than North Saginaw Charter Academy (1 vs. 0).
Subgroup Analysis
Comparing reported values between specific student populations where both schools have data.
15 subgroup comparisons available across both schools.
Reported Only at Carrollton Elementary School
1 metric was reported by Carrollton Elementary School. Comparable data for North Saginaw Charter Academy is missing or suppressed.
Students per counselor
602:1
Contextual Indicators
District Context
District-level data describes the overarching school district, not the individual school.
Per-pupil spending
North Saginaw Charter Academy
$13,969.7
Carrollton Elementary School
$17,513.98
Local revenue share
North Saginaw Charter Academy
4.9%
Carrollton Elementary School
13%
State revenue share
North Saginaw Charter Academy
70.5%
Carrollton Elementary School
78.4%
Federal revenue share
North Saginaw Charter Academy
24.6%
Carrollton Elementary School
8.6%
District chronic absenteeism rate
North Saginaw Charter Academy
57.6%
Carrollton Elementary School
45.5%
County Economics
Both schools are located in the same county.
Median household income
Saginaw County
$58,347
Saginaw County
$58,347
Poverty rate
Saginaw County
18.1%
Saginaw County
18.1%
Bachelor's degree or higher
Saginaw County
23.5%
Saginaw County
23.5%
Unemployment rate
Saginaw County
5.9%
Saginaw County
5.9%
This comparison is derived exclusively from publicly available federal and state datasets. It may not reflect the most current information. We encourage parents and families to supplement this data with information published directly on each school’s website, which may include more recent figures.