Original Research by School Decision on Mcnary Elementary District (4163)
McNary Elementary District is a small, rural K-8 district in Apache County, Arizona, serving the community of Greer and likely the unincorporated areas around McNary itself. The district operates a single school, McNary Elementary School, that covers preschool through eighth grade. Because the district ends at eighth grade, there is no high school, no graduation rate, and no advanced course metrics such as AP or dual enrollment that would apply to this grade span.
The student body is small, and the overwhelming majority of students are American Indian or Alaska Native. The remaining share is a tiny number of Black students and a negligible count of multiracial students; the district reports no White, Hispanic, Asian, or Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander students enrolled. A parent considering this district should understand that the peer environment is almost entirely Native American, and the district is located within the broader Apache County context, which includes the Fort Apache Indian Reservation.
State assessment data for the 2024-25 school year is almost entirely suppressed for all tested grades and subjects in math, English language arts, and science. The state of Arizona suppresses proficiency rates when the tested group is small enough to risk identifying individual students, and that is the case here. The tested counts per grade level range in the teens or twenties, well below the threshold for public reporting. The only available state-level figure is a multi-year trend point showing a proficiency rate for ELA when all grades are combined, but even that is a single snapshot from 2024-25. A parent will not be able to compare this district's academic performance to others in the state using the standard assessment results, because the data simply is not released. This is a structural reality of a very small district, not a sign that testing did not occur, but it does mean families have very limited information to evaluate instructional quality from state metrics alone.
The district is positioned among the districts of Apache County for a few measures where data exists. On chronic absenteeism, the district's rate falls in the top quartile, which in this context means a lower rate of chronic absence relative to most other districts in the county. That is a meaningful positive, as chronic absenteeism is a widespread challenge in rural Apache County. On per-pupil current spending, the district is in the upper range among the county's districts, indicating that the district invests relatively more per student than most other Apache County districts when it comes to day-to-day operating costs. No additional finance or staffing details are available.
No free-or-reduced-price lunch data, IEP counts, or English learner counts were reported, so the share of students in poverty or receiving special services is unknown. The district's Title I status is also not reported. A parent who wants to understand whether the district offers targeted supports for low-income students or students with disabilities will need to ask the school directly.
Housing context is thin. The available home value data pulls from the single ZIP code associated with Greer, showing a modest year-over-year decline in values. The estimated monthly mortgage payment at prevailing rates is well above what a typical national household income would support, but that figure reflects the entire national snapshot, not local incomes. Apache County is a large, rural, and economically varied area, and the housing stock in this part of the county is sparse.
The district brief turned up no recent changes to curriculum, facilities, property tax referendums, or governance that would meet a four-year relevance bar. The district appears to be operationally stable and unchanging in terms of public-facing shifts. A family moving here should expect the core experience to be a single, small rural elementary school serving a predominantly Native American student population, with very limited publicly available data on academic outcomes and no high school within the district.
See more original research from School Decision →