The top reported proficiency rate is 83% in English language arts. The lowest is 74% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on North Star Charter School Inc.
North Star Charter School Inc. is a single-school charter district in Idaho's Treasure Valley, serving students from kindergarten through twelfth grade. The enrollment is moderately sized for a charter operation, with the student body spread across all grade levels. Elementary grades run roughly evenly, each with a comparable cohort, while the middle school grades are somewhat larger. High school grades taper down considerably, with the upper grades being the smallest. This shape suggests many families join for the elementary and middle school years, and a portion of students transition elsewhere for high school, though a meaningful group stays through graduation.
The student population is predominantly white, with a Hispanic enrollment that represents the next largest group, and small numbers of Asian, multiracial, Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander, and American Indian or Alaska Native students. Free-or-reduced-price lunch data was not available, nor were counts for students with individualized education programs or English learners, so the economic and special-population picture is incomplete here. A parent wanting to understand how the school serves students from varied income backgrounds or those needing specialized support would want to ask the school directly.
On Idaho's ISAT assessments for the most recent school year, North Star's academic results are strong, particularly in the elementary grades. Third grade math proficiency is exceptionally high, with nearly all tested students reaching proficient or above. Fourth and fifth grade math remain strong, with a clear majority proficient. English language arts follows a similar pattern in the elementary band, with fifth grade results especially high. Some grade-level ELA and science results were reported as ranges rather than precise figures, which the state does to protect student privacy when the tested group is small. In those cases the ranges still suggest solid performance, though the uncertainty is worth noting.
The middle school grades show a dip. Sixth and eighth grade math proficiency lands at a level where roughly three in five students are proficient, which is lower than the elementary grades but still above what many schools achieve. Seventh grade math is moderately higher. English language arts holds up better through the middle grades, with seventh and eighth grade results remaining strong. Eighth grade science proficiency is solid, with roughly three-quarters of students proficient.
The school's structural context is changing in ways a parent should know about. North Star has announced a merger with Rolling Hills Charter, effective for the upcoming school year, which publicly reported materials describe as Idaho's first charter-to-charter merger. North Star serves as the lead organization. The merger restructures the campuses: North Star's current Eagle location becomes a joint elementary and middle school, and the high school relocates to a new site on North Horseshoe Bend Road in Boise, near the Optimist Youth Sports fields. For families with children in the upper grades, this means a different physical campus and likely a reshaped peer environment as the two student bodies combine.
Several things we looked for were not available. There is no locale brief or community economic context in the provided data, so the housing market and town character are not described here. No neighbor comparison fact-set was provided, so this district is not positioned against surrounding districts in the county. No graduation rate, program offerings, civil-rights data, discipline information, staffing ratios, attendance figures, or course-access details were available. These gaps mean a parent has an academic snapshot and an enrollment picture but lacks information on college and career pathways, extracurriculars, school climate, and teacher resources. A family considering North Star would benefit from asking the school about its high school course catalog, post-graduation outcomes, and how the merger will affect class sizes and program availability at each campus.
What the data does show is a charter school with a clear academic strength in its elementary program, where proficiency rates are among the higher end of what Idaho schools post. The middle grades are solid in literacy but show some softness in math that a parent may want to look into further with the school. The upcoming merger adds a layer of transition that will reshape the experience for current and incoming students, particularly at the high school level. For a family drawn to a smaller charter environment with a kindergarten-through-twelfth-grade pathway and strong early academic foundations, North Star presents a real option, with the caveat that the consolidation is still settling into place.
See more original research from School Decision →