Original Research by School Decision on Mccall Community School Inc
McCall Community School Inc. is a small charter district operating a single school, Mountain Community School, in Donnelly, Idaho. It serves students from kindergarten through eighth grade. The district's enrollment is small, with cohorts that vary in size from grade to grade but generally sit in the single digits to low teens. The student body is predominantly white, with a small number of students from other racial and ethnic backgrounds.
State assessment results for this district are almost entirely suppressed. Idaho's ISAT proficiency data for math, English language arts, and science shows no reportable proficiency rates across the tested grades. Science is assessed only in fifth and eighth grade, which is standard for Idaho. The suppression pattern is consistent with what you see in very small schools and districts, where the number of tested students in any given grade is low enough that the state withholds results to protect student privacy. A parent trying to judge academic outcomes from state testing data alone will find little to go on here.
The district does have a multi-year trend entry for ELA proficiency, but the data is limited and its reliability is questionable given the extremely small testing populations involved. We would not weight it heavily. A parent would be better served by asking the school directly about student performance and growth.
Several categories of information that parents often rely on are absent from the available data. Free-or-reduced-price lunch eligibility, which signals the economic makeup of the student body, was not reported. Special education and English learner populations were not available. The school's charter status, magnet designation, and Title I status were not provided in the structured data, though publicly reported material identifies it as an independent charter district. Civil rights data, including discipline and course access details, was not available. Staffing, attendance, and broader school environment information were also absent.
The community and economic context for Donnelly and the surrounding area was not provided in the data we received. Without a locale brief, we cannot speak to housing costs, population trends, or the broader economic picture a family would be stepping into. A parent considering this area would want to research Donnelly and Valley County directly.
A search for recent parent-relevant changes, such as curriculum shifts, bond measures, or property-tax adjustments, turned up nothing in the available public record. The available materials surfaced no lasting structural changes a family should know about.
The available data confirms a picture of a very small charter school in a mountain town, serving kindergarten through eighth grade, with a homogenous student body and no reportable state testing outcomes. The appeal of a school this size often comes down to individual attention, community closeness, and a particular educational philosophy, none of which the available data can confirm or describe. A parent would need to visit, talk with leadership, and ask pointed questions about academic approach, student support services, and how the school handles assessment and growth for a student body this small.
See more original research from School Decision →