The top reported proficiency rate is 64% in Science. The lowest is 48% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Grace Joint District
Grace Joint District is a small, rural Idaho district serving students from prekindergarten through twelfth grade across two schools: Black Canyon Elementary School and Grace Jr/Sr High School. The district sits in Caribou County, with housing data drawing from several communities including Grace, Bancroft, Downey, Lava Hot Springs, Preston, and Soda Springs. Grace itself carries the largest weight in the district's housing picture.
The enrollment is small, with each grade level typically holding between roughly thirty and fifty students. The student body is predominantly white, with a small Hispanic presence and only a handful of students from other racial or ethnic backgrounds. This is a homogeneous setting, which some families may see as familiar and close-knit while others may seek greater diversity. Free and reduced-price lunch data was not available, so the economic profile of the student body cannot be characterized from what was provided. Special population data, including individualized education program rates and English learner counts, was also missing.
On state assessments, Grace Joint District takes the Idaho ISAT, and the most recent results come from the current school year. Many grade-level results are reported as ranges rather than exact proficiency figures, a common practice when class sizes are small and student privacy must be protected. This means some results carry wide possible bands, and a parent reviewing them should treat the ranges as indicators rather than precise measurements.
Where exact proficiency was reported, the picture is mixed but includes some bright spots. Fourth-grade math proficiency landed above the midpoint, suggesting solid elementary instruction in that subject. Sixth-grade math came in below half, and sixth-grade ELA sat just under the midpoint. Fifth-grade science was a relative strength, with a clear majority of tested students reaching proficiency. For the remaining grades, the reported ranges vary widely. Some upper bounds are quite high, particularly in third-grade ELA and seventh-grade ELA, while others, especially in eighth-grade science, top out below half. These ranges reflect the reality of testing small cohorts, where a few students moving above or below the proficiency line can shift results considerably. A parent may want to ask the district how it tracks year-to-year performance given these fluctuations, and whether it uses additional assessments to complement the state test.
No graduation rate data was included in what we received, and Grace Jr/Sr High School does serve high school grades, so this is a gap worth noting. The district does not appear in any specialized program or course-access data, so information on Advanced Placement offerings, dual-credit partnerships, or career-technical pathways was not available. We searched for recent parent-relevant changes such as curriculum updates, referendums, or property tax shifts and found none publicly reported, so there is little to relay on that front.
Housing in the district is modestly priced relative to the Idaho state benchmark, sitting below it, and close to the national figure. Homes in the Grace area have seen steady appreciation recently. Lava Hot Springs and Preston carry higher home values within the district's footprint, while Downey and Soda Springs are more affordable. The estimated monthly mortgage for a typical home in the area is moderate, and the price-to-income ratio sits below levels common in more competitive markets. Rental data was not available. For families considering a move, the housing costs are relatively approachable compared with much of Idaho, though mortgage rates remain elevated by recent historical standards.
What Grace Joint District offers is a small-scale, rural educational pathway where class sizes stay manageable and students move through their schooling alongside the same peers year after year. The academic results show genuine strength in some elementary subjects, particularly science, with more variable performance in the middle grades. The absence of program data, graduation rates, and special-population figures means families evaluating this district should reach out directly to understand what the high school offers and how student support services are structured.
See more original research from School Decision →