The top reported proficiency rate is 55% in Science. The lowest is 45% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Island City Academy
Island City Academy is a single-school charter district serving kindergarten through eighth grade in the Eaton Rapids area of Eaton County, Michigan. It is a small school, with roughly two dozen students per grade level, which means every cohort is intimate and each year's state testing results rest on a small number of tested students. That context matters when reading the results: a few children moving in or out can shift a grade's proficiency picture considerably from one year to the next.
The student body is predominantly white, with a small number of Hispanic students and a handful of students from other racial backgrounds. Free-or-reduced-price lunch data, special education enrollment, and English learner figures were not available in the data provided, so we cannot characterize the economic profile or the level of specialized support populations from what is here. A parent considering the school may want to ask directly about these figures.
Academically, Island City Academy shows a distinctive pattern across its grade span. The earliest tested grades are strong in math, with third grade posting a solid majority proficient and fourth grade at about half. English language arts starts lower in third and fourth grade, with fewer than a third of students reaching proficiency. Both subjects dip in fifth and sixth grade, particularly math, where proficiency falls to roughly three in ten. The school regroups in the upper grades. By eighth grade, results jump sharply. On the PSAT-based measures for eighth grade, a large majority of students are proficient in ELA, a strong majority in math, and science and social studies proficiency is solid at both fifth and eighth grade. The eighth grade social studies result, with seven in ten proficient, is among the stronger outcomes in the data.
Measured against Eaton County's districts, Island City Academy's overall proficiency index sits in the top quartile, meaning its average proficiency across tested subjects and grades is among the higher figures in the county. Its chronic absenteeism rate also places in the top quartile, below the county median, which suggests students are showing up reliably. Per-pupil current spending is in the lower range among the county's districts, below the county median. Because the school stops at eighth grade, there is no graduation rate to report, which is expected for a K-8 entity and not a gap in performance.
No locale brief was available for the surrounding community, and no district-level program offerings, staffing details, discipline data, or course-access information were provided. The district brief search found no recent changes clearing a lasting-impact threshold, so there is nothing new to report on that front. State participation rates for the assessments were also missing across all grades and subjects.
What the data does support is a picture of a small, community-oriented charter school where the academic trajectory builds toward a strong finish. The middle-grade dip in math and ELA is a pattern a parent would want to understand. The eighth grade outcomes, taken alongside the upper-quartile proficiency ranking among Eaton County's districts, suggest the school is doing something effective in those later years. Whether the dip in grades five and six reflects a transition the school is actively addressing is worth asking about directly. For families seeking a small K-8 setting where their child will be known and where the upper grades produce strong results, Island City Academy presents a reasonable case, with the caveat that several key data points on economic diversity and specialized populations were not available.
See more original research from School Decision →