The top reported proficiency rate is 13% in English language arts. The lowest is 7% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Benton Harbor Charter School Academy
Benton Harbor Charter School Academy is a single-school charter district in Berrien County, Michigan, serving students from pre-kindergarten through ninth grade, though its ninth-grade enrollment is empty, so in practice it operates as an early-childhood through middle-grade school. The academy sits in Benton Harbor, a small city in southwestern Michigan near the Lake Michigan shore. No locale brief was provided for the community, so this account sticks to what the school's own data shows.
The student body is small for a district, with enrollment that has declined steadily by grade, so the upper grades have far fewer students than the early elementary classrooms. The school serves an almost entirely Black student population, with a very small number of Hispanic students and almost none from other racial groups. This is a homogeneous peer environment in demographic terms, which some families may see as a culturally affirming setting and others may want to weigh alongside the academic picture. Free-or-reduced-price lunch data was not reported, so the economic profile of the enrolled families cannot be characterized from the available information. Special-population data for students with individualized education programs and English learners was also missing.
On Michigan's M-STEP and PSAT assessments, the school's results are low across every tested subject and grade. In math, proficiency rates sit in the single digits for third and fourth grade, and in the lowest reporting band for fifth through eighth grade, with zero students reaching proficiency in several of those grades. English language arts follows a similar pattern, with fourth grade showing the strongest result at roughly one in ten students proficient, and eighth grade reaching about a fifth of tested students on the PSAT. Science and social studies results, tested in fifth and eighth grade, also land in the lowest bands with no students demonstrating proficiency. Against Berrien County's nineteen districts, the school's overall proficiency index places it in the bottom quartile, well below the county median. These are difficult numbers. A parent considering this school would want to ask directly what academic improvement plans are in place and how the school supports students working below grade level.
Chronic absenteeism is a serious concern here. The school's rate is in the bottom quartile among Berrien County districts, far above the county median, which means a large proportion of students are missing substantial instructional time. This level of absenteeism compounds the academic challenges visible in the test data and is something a family would want to understand before enrolling. Whether the causes are transportation, health, family circumstances, or school climate is not clear from the data, so this is a question worth raising with school leadership.
Per-pupil spending sits in the middle range of the county's districts, slightly below the county median, so the school is funded at a level comparable to many of its neighbors. No data on staffing ratios, course access, discipline, or program offerings was available, so those dimensions cannot be described. The school does not report a graduation rate, which is expected because it does not operate a full high school graduating class. No multi-year trend data was provided, so whether performance is improving or declining over time cannot be determined.
No district brief with parent-relevant recent changes was found. Publicly available sources returned only routine enrollment and school information, so there is nothing to report on curriculum shifts, fiscal changes, or policy updates. A family evaluating this school should treat that absence as a gap and ask the school directly for its strategic priorities and any recent initiatives.
What the data paints is a small, demographically focused charter school with deep academic challenges and high absenteeism, spending at a middling level among its Berrien County peers, and with limited publicly available information about its programs, staffing, or improvement plans. For a parent, the most productive next step would be a direct conversation with school leadership about how they are addressing both proficiency and attendance, and what supports exist for students performing below grade level.
See more original research from School Decision →