The top reported proficiency rate is 33% in English language arts. The lowest is 17% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Bay City Academy
Bay City Academy is a charter district serving prekindergarten through twelfth grade across two campuses in Michigan, one in Bay City and another in Mancelona. The enrollment is small for a district spanning all grade levels, with roughly equal distribution across grades from kindergarten through senior year. The student body is predominantly white, with a modest share identifying as two or more races and smaller Hispanic and Black populations. Free-or-reduced-price lunch counts were not reported, and data on special education and English learner populations was not available, so a parent would need to ask the school directly for details on how it serves economically disadvantaged students and students with specialized needs.
On state assessments, the district's results paint a mixed picture. English language arts is the relative strength. Proficiency rates climb as students move through the grades, with the strongest showing in eighth grade, where a clear majority of tested students reached proficiency on the PSAT-based measure. Middle grade ELA performance generally outpaces the elementary grades, where proficiency starts lower in third grade and builds. A parent looking at these numbers would see a district where literacy instruction appears to gain traction over time, particularly in the upper elementary and middle school years.
Math is a softer area. Proficiency rates across grades three through eight are consistently low, with the best result in seventh grade still representing only about a quarter of tested students. Fifth grade math proficiency is particularly low. This pattern held across the most recent testing cycle. Science and social studies results fall between the ELA and math extremes, with science proficiency stronger in eighth grade than in fifth, and social studies following a similar upward trajectory. A parent may want to look into how the school supports math instruction and intervention, especially in the elementary and early middle grades, where the gaps are widest.
Among Bay County's districts, Bay City Academy's overall proficiency sits in the bottom quartile. Its chronic absenteeism rate is below the midpoint of the county group, which is a concern worth discussing with the school, as absenteeism compounds academic difficulties. Per-pupil current spending sits in the lower range compared to neighboring districts, which may shape the breadth of resources and supports available in classrooms.
The district operates two open campuses. North Central Academy Campus and the Farragut Campus serve the district's students, though the data does not break down enrollment or performance by campus, so a parent cannot tell from these figures alone whether one site differs from the other. Visiting both would help clarify which environment fits a given child.
A few things a parent should know are simply absent from the available data. No graduation rate was reported for this district, so the high school years cannot be evaluated through that lens here. No housing, rent, or community economic context was provided, which limits the sense of what neighborhoods or towns feed into the schools. No information on advanced coursework, career pathways, extracurriculars, staffing ratios, or discipline was available. The district brief turned up no recent news or reports of lasting, parent-relevant changes, so there is little to say about recent strategic direction or shifts in programming. Where these gaps matter to a family, the school itself is the next stop.
What the available evidence suggests is a small, full-spectrum charter district where literacy is the academic bright spot, math is the area of clearest concern, and absenteeism is elevated relative to nearby districts. For a family weighing this option, the strengths in upper-grade reading and writing are real, and the math and attendance patterns are worth direct conversation with school leadership before deciding.
See more original research from School Decision →