Original Research by School Decision on Medicine Lake K-12 Schools
Medicine Lake K-12 Schools is a small, rural district serving the town of Medicine Lake and the surrounding area in Sheridan County, northeastern Montana. It operates three distinct buildings: Medicine Lake School, Medicine Lake High School, and Medicine Lake 7-8, covering pre-kindergarten through twelfth grade under a single administration.
The district is very small, with enrollment roughly the size of a single urban elementary school spread across all grade levels. The student body is predominantly white, with small shares of American Indian or Alaska Native students and Hispanic students, along with a few students identifying as two or more races. Data on the share of students who qualify for free or reduced-price meals was not available, nor was information on students with disabilities or English learners.
Academic performance data is limited and should be interpreted with caution. State testing results for mathematics and English language arts for grades three through eight were suppressed for the most recent year, meaning the student group was too small to report. This is common in very small districts, where a handful of students can make results personally identifiable. Science testing data was missing entirely. One piece of information was reported: in math, the number of students who scored proficient or above was reported even as the rate was suppressed, but this single count does not allow for comparison to other schools or districts.
Because the district serves all grade levels, the lack of high school state testing data in this profile means no graduation rate was available, and the district’s overall proficiency ranking could not be calculated among its peers. Readers should note that the absence of these metrics is driven as much by the district's size and the state's data suppression rules as by any measure of performance.
What can be compared is chronic absenteeism. Among the Sheridan County districts with available data, Medicine Lake K-12 Schools had a chronic absenteeism rate in the bottom quartile—meaning a higher share of students missed substantial school time than in most neighboring districts. A parent may want to look into this further with the school to understand what drives the pattern and what supports exist.
On the finance side, the district’s per-pupil current spending fell in the upper range among Sheridan County’s four districts. This is common for very small, geographically large rural districts, where fixed costs like transportation and facilities are spread over a low number of students.
Housing in the district’s area is affordable compared to state and national benchmarks. The weighted home value estimate for the zip codes that feed the district was below the Montana average and below the national average, with modest year-over-year appreciation. A typical household would find the estimated monthly mortgage payment, using prevailing interest rates, to be relatively low. The town of Medicine Lake itself is small, and the nearest larger center is Plentywood, which also contributes to the district’s housing market.
We looked for recent district changes, strategic priorities, or notable developments through public reporting and found little of lasting impact to include. This is a small, stable rural district without recent headline events.
For a family considering this district, the picture is one of a very small, community-rooted school system in a low-cost housing market. The size means every student is known, class groups are intimate, and the district offers the full K-12 pathway without the anonymity of a larger school. The trade-offs are limited academic course offerings compared to larger schools (program data was not provided but can be assumed from the size), a higher chronic absenteeism rate that warrants a conversation, and the reality that many performance metrics will be suppressed by the state due to low student counts, making it hard to compare on test scores alone. This is a place that likely works well for families who value close community ties and a manageable, predictable environment over wide programmatic choice and high-stakes academic benchmarking.
See more original research from School Decision →