Original Research by School Decision on Success Academy Charter School-upper West
Success Academy Charter School-Upper West is a charter school serving students in the Upper West Side area of Manhattan. The school has undergone a significant structural change starting in the 2025-26 school year: it converted from a K-8 school into a K-4 elementary school, with middle school students now attending Success Academy Hell's Kitchen. This is a lasting change that means families enrolling at Upper West will not have a single-site path through middle school but will instead transition their children to a different Success Academy location for grades 5-8.
The enrollment across the school spans from kindergarten through eighth grade, with the largest concentration in the upper elementary grades. The student population reflects the demographics of the broader Upper West Side: roughly equal shares identify as Hispanic, Asian, and White, with a substantial Black population and smaller shares across other racial and ethnic groups. Data on free-and-reduced-price lunch rates and special populations including students with disabilities and English learners was not available in the school's reported information.
Success Academy operates independently as a charter entity rather than as a traditional public school district. This means enrollment decisions, curriculum, and operations follow the charter's governance structure and oversight rather than the Department of Education's standard district model. Among the chartered and traditional districts serving New York County, Success Academy Upper West ranks in the top quartile on chronic absenteeism, meaning the school's absenteeism rate is notably lower than the median. Spending per pupil falls in the lower range compared to other county districts, reflecting the efficiency model often associated with charter networks.
Academic proficiency data and graduation rates for the school were not available in the reported materials. State testing results and college readiness outcomes would help a family understand how students are tracking academically compared to other schools in the county. A parent considering enrollment may want to contact the school directly to discuss recent test score results, the specific curriculum and instructional approach, and support services for students with different learning needs.
The transition to K-4 structure means that Upper West is now positioned as an elementary entry point rather than as a school families can attend through eighth grade. Families planning beyond fourth grade will need to plan a transition to the Hell's Kitchen location or seek options elsewhere.
See more original research from School Decision →