The top reported proficiency rate is 53% in Science. The lowest is 37% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on New Shoreham
New Shoreham is a single-school district serving Block Island, Rhode Island, with Block Island School as its only campus. The school covers grades one through twelve, and the total enrollment is small enough that each grade level holds roughly a dozen students or fewer. This is one of the most geographically isolated school districts in the state, sitting on an island miles off the Rhode Island coast, and that isolation shapes nearly everything about the educational experience here.
The student body is predominantly white, with a Hispanic population that makes up a meaningful minority of the class. A handful of students identify as two or more races, and there is minimal representation from other racial or ethnic groups. The district did not report free-or-reduced-price lunch data, special education enrollment, or English learner figures, so it is hard to gauge the full range of student needs from the available information. A parent may want to ask the school directly about how it supports students who require individualized education plans or language services, since those data are not in the public record reviewed here.
On state assessments, New Shoreham's results tell a mixed but generally solid story for a community of this size. In English language arts, roughly half of tested students in grades three through eight reached proficiency, which is a respectable showing. Math proficiency landed below that, with a little more than a third of students meeting the state standard. Science results varied sharply by grade level. Fifth-grade science proficiency was on the lower side, while eighth-grade science was a clear strength, with a strong majority of students demonstrating proficiency. Participation rates were high across all tested subjects, which matters because small cohorts can produce volatile year-to-year swings. These results come from a single grade cohort of a dozen or fewer students at each level, so a family reading them should keep in mind that a few children moving in or out can shift the picture considerably from one year to the next.
No multi-year trend data was available, which limits the ability to say whether performance is improving, holding steady, or slipping. The district brief search also turned up no specific parent-relevant changes or initiatives from recent years. This is a very small, stable operation, and the absence of documented strategic shifts may simply reflect that continuity rather than neglect. Still, a parent looking for evidence of new programming or academic reform would not find much in the public record to go on.
The housing market in New Shoreham is among the most expensive in the country. The typical home value sits at roughly three and a half times the state benchmark and nearly five times the national one. The price-to-income ratio is extreme, meaning that purchasing a home here requires an income far above what most households earn. Rent data was not available, but the overall cost of shelter in the region has been climbing steadily. For families considering a move, the housing barrier is real. This is a community where year-round residency is a serious financial commitment, and the school reflects the realities of a small island population rather than the resources of a wealthy suburb.
What New Shoreham offers is intimacy and continuity. Children grow up with the same classmates from first grade through twelfth, in a single building, on an island. The academic results are uneven but not alarming, with genuine strengths in middle-grade science and respectable reading performance. Math is the soft spot, and a parent may want to look into how the school supports math instruction across the grade levels. The isolation that defines Block Island is both the district's defining characteristic and its central constraint.
See more original research from School Decision →