The top reported proficiency rate is 24% in English language arts. The lowest is 2% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Smith Middle School
Smith Middle School serves grades six through eight in Birmingham, Alabama, as a regular public school within the Birmingham City district. It sits in the 35215 zip code, an area where housing values fall below the state median and where rents are modest compared to national benchmarks. The school’s enrollment is small for a middle school, and the student body is predominantly Black, with a substantial Hispanic minority and only a handful of white students. A very high share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting concentrated poverty in the surrounding neighborhoods.
On state assessments, academic proficiency rates are low across all tested subjects. In reading, about a third of sixth graders met proficiency, a share that drops to roughly a quarter in seventh grade and falls to about one in seven in eighth grade. Math proficiency is far weaker: only a very small percentage of students at each grade level scored proficient. In science, tested in eighth grade, fewer than one in ten students reached proficiency. These results place Smith Middle School in the bottom quartile among its peers—a comparison relative to districts in Jefferson County. Only one year of data is available, so no trend can be assessed. The school does not serve the grades that produce a graduation rate, so that metric is not applicable.
The district, Birmingham City, is in the middle of significant change. A 2023 consolidation plan addresses declining enrollment and aging infrastructure, merging and repurposing schools through a phased plan. A new Career Tech Academy opened for high school students, expanding pathways in healthcare, IT, and advanced manufacturing; that opportunity becomes relevant when students leave Smith for high school. Meanwhile, the Alabama Literacy Act’s third-grade retention requirement has prompted the district to add reading coaches and intervention programs, though Smith Middle’s own literacy results suggest that many students arrive from elementary school already behind.
The community context is Birmingham itself, a mid-sized city that has seen its population gradually decline and which lost its status as Alabama’s largest city to Huntsville after the 2020 census. The city remains the anchor of a large metropolitan area and has a diversified economy built around banking, healthcare, education, and manufacturing. Downtown redevelopment and events like the World Games have spurred some revitalization, though the city continues to compete with its own suburbs for households and businesses. Birmingham claims more green space per capita than any comparably sized city, with landmarks like Railroad Park, Ruffner Mountain, and the Birmingham Civil Rights National Monument. The public school system operates across the city’s wide geography, and Smith Middle is one of its regular neighborhood schools.
Data on discipline, attendance, staffing, and course access were not available for this school. A parent may want to ask the school directly about student behavior patterns, chronic absenteeism, and the range of elective or enrichment offerings for middle schoolers. Similarly, the school’s special education and English learner populations are not reported in the available data, and those figures would be useful for understanding the full picture of student support.
Smith Middle School is a high-poverty, majority-Black school in a district undergoing consolidation and reform, serving a city that is economically important but has lost population. The academic results are a clear concern, especially in mathematics, where proficiency is almost nonexistent. A parent considering this school will want to investigate what interventions, tutoring, or extended learning opportunities are in place and how the school’s feeder high school—particularly in light of the district’s new career academy—might shape the long-term academic and vocational path for a child enrolled here.
See more original research from School Decision →