The top reported proficiency rate is 61% in English language arts. The lowest is 31% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Harlan Elementary School
Harlan Elementary School serves a population that is notably different from the broader Florence community. The school’s student body reflects a high level of economic need, with a substantial share of students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch. Racially, the school is a mix of Black students, white students, and students who identify as two or more races, with smaller groups of Hispanic and Asian students. This composition gives Harlan a diverse peer environment, though one that is not representative of Florence’s overall demographic profile. The school serves grades pre-kindergarten through fourth grade, making it an early-elementary entry point for many families in the city.
Harlan Elementary’s academic results draw a picture of uneven performance by grade level and subject, a pattern that parents will want to examine. On the state’s assessments, third-grade mathematics proficiency was low, while fourth-grade math was higher and fifth-grade math reached a level that many would consider a strong showing for a school with this level of economic need. In English language arts, the trajectory was similar: third grade was about average, fourth grade was slightly below, and fifth-grade proficiency was well above what is typical for a school serving this demographic. Fourth-grade science results were low. When combined across all tested grades and subjects, the school’s overall proficiency index placed it in the bottom quartile relative to other districts in Lauderdale County. That comparison, however, includes only two districts in the county, Florence City and the Lauderdale County public schools, so the spread is narrow. Within the school itself, the gap between third-grade and fifth-grade results is wide, and a parent may want to ask the school how it supports students in the earlier grades and whether those cohorts tend to accelerate as they move up.
No data was reported on chronic absenteeism or on student discipline, so it is not possible to assess the school’s attendance climate or behavioral environment from the available information. The district, Florence City Schools, had no publicly reported recent changes or strategic initiatives that would affect Harlan specifically, so the school appears to be operating within a stable district context.
Harlan is located in Florence, the largest city in the Shoals region of northwestern Alabama. Florence is a mix of historic downtown commercial buildings, the University of North Alabama campus, and residential neighborhoods. The economy includes manufacturing, food processing, agriculture, timber, and a growing tourism sector anchored by annual events like the W.C. Handy Music Festival and the Alabama Renaissance Faire. The city describes itself as experiencing steady economic growth and business expansion. The presence of the university, the Tennessee Valley Authority, and several manufacturing sectors provide a base of major employers. Housing values in the area around the school are below the state median, and rents are moderate relative to incomes, making Florence a relatively affordable place to live.
The school itself operates in a regular public school setting, with no charter or magnet designation. No data was available on whether it receives Title I funding, though given the high level of need among its students, it would likely qualify. The school does not serve grades that have a graduation rate to report, which is expected for a PK-04 elementary school. No data was available on special education or English learner populations, so the school’s support infrastructure for those students is not something a parent can evaluate from this data. A family considering Harlan should look into how the school differentiates instruction and provides supports, especially in the early primary years where math results were weakest, and ask about the school’s approach to building literacy and numeracy skills from kindergarten through fourth grade.
See more original research from School Decision →