Original Research by School Decision on Star Charter School
STAR Charter School in Flagstaff serves a small, tightly-knit student body across kindergarten through eighth grade. The school is a single-site charter authorized under Painted Desert Demonstration Projects Inc., operating as a regular school. Its enrollment, drawn from the Flagstaff area, is small for a K–8 campus, and the student population is almost entirely Native American. The remaining students are a mix of children who identify with two or more races, a small number of Hispanic students, and a very small number of white students. The grade-level numbers are evenly spread, with each grade having a handful of children. Data on the share of students who qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, receive special education services, or are English learners is not available in the public record, which a parent may want to clarify directly with the school.
The academic assessment picture is limited. For the 2024–25 school year, Arizona administered the AASA (Arizona Academic Standards Assessment) in math and English language arts to students in grades three through eight, and the AzSci science assessment to grades five and eight. At STAR Charter School, proficiency rates for all tested subjects and all tested grade levels were suppressed by the state, meaning the numbers are withheld from public reporting because the group size falls below the state’s minimum threshold. This suppression does not necessarily reflect a weak or strong performance; it is a direct outcome of the school’s very small grade-level enrollments. The state did report the number of tested students for most grade-subject combinations, and those tested counts are in the range of a single classroom. A multi-year trend file shows a single-year point for English language arts at the school level, which is an orphan data point with no prior or subsequent comparison available, so it is not useful for understanding direction. A parent seeking to understand academic performance at STAR Charter School will not find standardized test scores to evaluate and may want to ask the school directly about its own internal assessments and how students progress year to year.
Because the school ends at eighth grade, there is no graduation rate to report, and the absence is explained by the grade band. There is no data on discipline, chronic absenteeism, course access, or staffing in the available records. The comparison with other districts in Coconino County was attempted for proficiency, graduation, and chronic absenteeism, but each metric was flagged as not applicable because the school’s own value was missing. This means STAR Charter School cannot be placed relative to its county peers on those standard academic measures.
Flagstaff itself is a city of mountain and high-desert character, dominated by Northern Arizona University, tourism that draws on the Grand Canyon and nearby national monuments, and federal science installations. The historic downtown built from local red sandstone has been revitalized and is a distinct center of commerce and civic life. Housing values in Flagstaff are high, running well above the national median, and rents are also elevated. The 30-year fixed mortgage rate at the time of this analysis was moderate, and the national unemployment rate was low. A family looking at STAR Charter School is likely making a choice based on the school’s small size, its cultural composition and location in the city, and the particular program it offers, rather than on the academic metrics that dominate the public conversation about larger schools. The school’s charter status means it operates independently of the local district, so parents choose it through the state’s open enrollment system.
See more original research from School Decision →