The top reported proficiency rate is 58% in English language arts. The lowest is 30% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Carmichael Elementary School
Carmichael Elementary School is a regular public school serving prekindergarten through sixth grade in Sierra Vista, Arizona. It operates as part of the Sierra Vista Unified District and sits in a city shaped by the presence of Fort Huachuca, a U.S. Army post that is the area’s dominant employer and economic anchor. Nearly half of all local jobs are government positions, and the professional, scientific, and technical services sector is unusually large due to Army contracts. Sierra Vista has a suburban, low-density character with strip commercial corridors, a public transit system, and a mix of military personnel, students, families, and retirees. Housing values and rents are moderate compared to statewide benchmarks, and the community has experienced modest growth in recent decades.
The school itself is small in enrollment, which is a notable characteristic for its grade band. The student body is diverse: the largest share of students are Hispanic, with substantial white enrollment and smaller but present populations of Black, multiracial, and Asian students. No data on economic disadvantage or special education classification was available in the source materials, so families should inquire directly with the school about those supports.
On state assessments, the results are mixed and incomplete. For grades three through five in math and English language arts, proficiency rates are suppressed in the public data due to small testing groups, a common privacy protection. This means the school’s performance for those grade levels cannot be evaluated from this data alone. For sixth grade, where results are reported, English language arts proficiency exceeded half of test-takers, while mathematics proficiency was lower. Science results for fifth grade fell below half. Across all tested subjects and grades combined, the school’s overall proficiency index lands above the midpoint when placed against districts in Cochise County, suggesting that where data is available, the school performs relatively well compared to neighboring districts. However, parents who rely on test data to gauge academic strength will find gaps that make a complete picture elusive, and a direct conversation with the school about grade-level outcomes and instructional approaches would be worthwhile.
No information about program offerings, course access, or extracurriculars was provided. The district brief identified no recent parent-relevant changes such as bond elections, curriculum shifts, or property tax adjustments.
This is an elementary school that serves a community built around a military installation and government employment. The student population is diverse and the enrollment size is small. Academic data is partially obscured by suppression, but where it is available and when aggregated district-wide, performance is above the midpoint within the county. Families considering this school will likely want to follow up on academic specifics and program availability, and the suppressed data is not a sign of weakness but a statistical feature that limits public reporting. The school fits most naturally for those who value a small, diverse elementary setting in a stable, military-connected community with moderate housing costs.
See more original research from School Decision →