The top reported proficiency rate is 37% in Math. The lowest is 28% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Kathryn Sue Simonton Elementary
Kathryn Sue Simonton Elementary serves students from prekindergarten through sixth grade as a regular public school in the J O Combs Unified School District, located in the fast-growing Phoenix suburb of Queen Creek. The school sits in a community that has transformed from its agricultural roots into a sprawling residential area of master-planned subdivisions, pecan groves, and working farms, all set within a car-dependent landscape where most errands require driving. Home values in the zip code are well above the national median, and the housing market reflects the area’s rapid new-build expansion; rents are also comparatively high. Queen Creek lacks scheduled public transit and a traditional walkable downtown, though the town has a civic core anchored by the library and a community college satellite campus. Families moving here tend to be looking for suburban space and newer homes, and the school serves as a neighborhood anchor within that setting.
Academically, the school’s performance on Arizona’s state assessments places it above the midpoint among districts across Pinal County when looking at overall proficiency across tested subjects and grades. That relative position, however, masks a mixed picture by grade level and subject. In third grade, about two out of five students scored proficient in both math and English language arts, a level that falls short of a strong majority but is not out of step with many schools in the region. By fourth grade, proficiency rates dropped noticeably in both subjects, and fifth and sixth grade math results were suppressed from public reporting due to small group sizes, making it impossible to draw a clear comparison for those grades. In fifth grade science, the share of students reaching proficiency was similar to the lower end of the math and ELA results. The overall trend across available data from recent years shows a pattern that is uneven: some grades perform modestly better than others, and the school has not established a consistently high bar across all tested years.
The student body is diverse but predominantly White, with a substantial Hispanic presence, smaller Black and multiracial shares, and a very small number of Asian and Native American students. Data on economic disadvantage, special education, and English learner status was not reported, so a parent cannot determine from the available information how many students receive free or reduced-price meals or language support. The school’s size is moderate for an elementary, with an enrollment that creates a manageable scale but still large enough to offer grade-level peers across several sections.
The J O Combs district, which operates this school, recently secured voter approval for a budget override that will provide additional annual funding for teacher and staff pay, special education, arts and music, physical education, class size management, and extracurricular programs. The district also adopted a multi-year strategic plan centered on student achievement, school culture, operational efficiency, and community engagement. These district-level moves suggest a community that is willing to invest in its schools, though the effect on day-to-day classroom experience at Simonton will depend on how those dollars are distributed among the district’s campuses.
For a family considering this school, the context matters. The housing market is expensive but reflects an area of strong growth and new infrastructure. The school sits within a district that has a recent record of financial and planning initiatives. Academically, the school is performing above the midpoint of its county peers, but the absolute proficiency rates — especially in the middle elementary grades — are modest and uneven. A parent may want to look into how the school supports students who are not yet meeting benchmarks, and whether the suppressed results for some grade levels reflect small class sizes or other factors worth asking about directly. The absence of data on special populations and economic need also leaves a gap that only a conversation with the school can fill. Overall, this is a suburban elementary school in a growing, car-oriented community, with academic outcomes that are middle of the pack for its county but inconsistent across grades and subjects.
See more original research from School Decision →