The top reported proficiency rate is 75% in English language arts. The lowest is 55% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Matthew Turner Elementary
Matthew Turner Elementary is a small kindergarten-through-fifth elementary school in Benicia serving about five hundred students. The school sits within Benicia Unified, a district facing sustained fiscal pressure from declining enrollment, though the district has made deliberate recent changes to literacy and math instruction that shape the learning experience at Turner.
The school's most recent test results show solid proficiency in English language arts, with about three-quarters of students meeting grade-level standards across grades three through five, and stronger performance in fourth grade. Mathematics results are somewhat softer, with proficiency ranging from the mid-60s in fifth grade to the mid-70s in grades three and four. Science proficiency at the fifth-grade level, the only grade tested, sits noticeably lower than reading and math. This pattern, where science trails other subjects, is common at elementary schools where science instruction often receives less time.
The student body is diverse in composition. White students make up the largest single group, followed by students of mixed or multiple races, Hispanic students, Asian students, and small numbers of Black and Native Hawaiian/Pacific Islander students. A modest share of the student population qualifies for free or reduced-price meals, suggesting the school serves some families with lower incomes but overall draws from a relatively stable economic community. Data on students with disabilities and English learners was not available in the sources reviewed.
Compared to other districts across Solano County, Turner's overall proficiency sits in the top quartile, a genuine strength. The school is neither exceptionally large nor especially small for its grade band; enrollment is spread fairly evenly across grades, with slightly higher numbers in the lower grades.
The wider context matters. Benicia itself is a historic waterfront town with a walkable downtown anchored by First Street, though school facilities sit on separate suburban campuses rather than within the downtown core. The community has experienced economic disruption: the Valero refinery, which employed a large share of Benicia's workforce, ceased fuel production in 2026, creating significant uncertainty about employment and tax revenue. The city is managing growth through an urban growth boundary and infill development, which constrains sprawl but also keeps housing costs elevated relative to income.
Benicia Unified has undertaken curriculum shifts that touch Turner directly. Teachers across the elementary grades received training in the Science of Reading, and the district adopted a new reading curriculum (Wonders 2023) for K-5. This curriculum and pedagogy change is something families weigh heavily; if you are familiar with the district's prior approach, instruction looks different now. The district has also adopted a new human growth and development curriculum for fifth graders, among other grades, another content change worth noting if that aligns or conflicts with your family's values.
The district's budget environment remains tight. Enrollment has trended downward over the past decade and is projected to fall further, creating pressure on staffing, program breadth, and class sizes. Reserves are declining, and the district has signaled that layoffs and further cuts may follow state budget actions. Turner's own staffing and program offerings will ride on this district-wide financial trajectory.
On the positive side, the community passed a substantial school bond (Measure C in 2024) that funds facility repairs and renovations across district schools, including Turner. This means improved and maintained buildings are underway, though the bond raises property taxes over roughly a generation.
Turner appears to be a school with solid, above-county-average test proficiency and a diverse, relatively economically stable student body. The mix of a recent curriculum overhaul, modest science results, and budget pressures across the district are factors to weigh as you consider fit for your family.
See more original research from School Decision →