The top reported proficiency rate is 21% in English language arts. The lowest is 17% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Eliot Elementary
Eliot Elementary serves kindergarten through fifth grade in Gilroy, a mid-sized city in Santa Clara County that has grown substantially in recent years. The school sits in a community where the majority of residents are Hispanic, where most families qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, and where the local economy centers on education, health care, agriculture, and large-scale retail. Gilroy itself is largely car-dependent but has a walkable downtown district and sits on a transit corridor served by Caltrain and VTA bus lines, about a short distance south of San Jose.
The school's academic standing presents a significant challenge. State testing data from the most recent school year shows proficiency in English language arts at around a fifth to a third of students across the tested grades, depending on the grade level, and mathematics proficiency ranging from around a sixth to a quarter of students. Science proficiency in grade five is similarly low. When ranked against the county's districts on an overall proficiency index, Eliot falls into the bottom quartile. These results reflect a broad pattern of academic difficulty that extends across the grades served.
The student body is predominantly Hispanic with a substantial English-learner population, though specific counts were not available in the data. About four-fifths of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, a marker of economic need that is high for the school. Enrollment sits at a moderate size for an elementary school, with the largest grades in kindergarten and fourth grade.
Eliot is part of Gilroy Unified, a district navigating significant structural pressures. Enrollment across the district has declined well below its historical peak and is expected to continue falling, which reduces state funding and periodically prompts closures or consolidations of schools. The district maintains a well-regarded Spanish-English Dual Immersion program, though it has been redistributed across multiple elementary campuses in recent years as enrollment has shrunk. A ballot measure has been proposed that would fund facility modernization and career technical education pathways, though passage would raise property taxes locally. These district-level changes affect capacity planning and school assignments over time.
The broader Gilroy housing market reflects a region under growth pressure. Home values are well above both state and national benchmarks, and rent is climbing. Many families in the school's attendance area are renters, and the cost of living is substantial relative to median household income. New residential development is concentrated on the city's west side at Glen Loma Ranch and nearby areas, which is reshaping the city's geography and may over time shift the location of the school-age population.
For a family considering Eliot, the main question is not whether the school is high-performing by state or county standards, but rather what kind of support for foundational academic skills the school provides, what the path forward looks like for a child entering below proficiency, and whether that school-level response aligns with the family's own academic expectations and resources at home. The low test results are a fact that warrants direct conversation with the school about instructional approaches, assessment practices, supplemental programs, and the demographic and economic realities the school is working within. This is a school serving a population with substantial economic need and English-learning complexity; a parent should ask specifically how the school addresses that profile and what growth looks like year to year.
See more original research from School Decision →