Original Research by School Decision on Mt. Madonna High
Mt. Madonna High is an alternative high school serving juniors and seniors in Gilroy, a fast-growing town in southern Santa Clara County about an hour south of San Jose. The school enrolls a small student body, with the vast majority of students in twelfth grade, and serves a population that is heavily Hispanic and economically disadvantaged. A substantial share of enrolled students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch.
The school's most recent state test results show proficiency rates well below the county median across all three tested subjects. In English language arts, proficiency was low; in mathematics it was lower still; and in science, no students met the proficiency standard. These figures represent the school's current measured academic performance and reflect the population it serves. The data available is limited to a single year, so trend information is not present. A parent may want to look into the school's specific support structures and instructional approach directly with administration, particularly around why these outcomes have emerged and what interventions are in place.
Alternative schools by design serve students who have not thrived in traditional comprehensive high school settings. They often enroll students who are older, coming back to finish high school after leaving, meeting specific behavioral or academic needs, or seeking a different instructional model. Mt. Madonna's enrollment pattern, with minimal freshmen and sophomores and a dominant senior cohort, is consistent with this mission. The school's demographic profile, dominated by a single racial and ethnic group and a high poverty rate, means the peers students encounter are largely from families facing economic strain, which shapes both the peer culture and the available family networks within the school community.
Gilroy itself is a town in transition. Historically known for agriculture and food processing, it has become one of California's faster-growing cities, with substantial new residential development on the west side, particularly at Glen Loma Ranch. A county facilities master plan identified long-standing facility needs across the district, and a bond measure was placed before voters. The town has a walkable downtown centered on Monterey Street with restaurants, galleries, and local retail, but overall is car-oriented. It is served by Caltrain and VTA bus transit, with a transit center near downtown, though most residents rely on personal vehicles.
The district that operates Mt. Madonna, Gilroy Unified, is facing sustained enrollment decline, having dropped well below its historical peak. This has prompted ongoing discussions about school closures and program realignment. The district operates a well-regarded Spanish-English Dual Immersion program, one of only a handful in California that spans preschool through twelfth grade, though the district has restructured which elementary schools host which grade levels as enrollment has tightened. Families in the district should be aware that capacity pressures can lead to changes in school assignments and program locations.
State testing data for the district's comprehensive high schools and most other schools was not available for this analysis, which would provide context for how Mt. Madonna's results compare to Gilroy High and other schools in the same system. Because Mt. Madonna is an alternative school, expectations around graduation rate and other standard metrics differ from those for comprehensive schools; those metrics are not reported here because they do not apply in the same way. A parent or student considering Mt. Madonna should plan to speak directly with the school about its approach to academics and student support, its graduation timeline, and how it serves students who have struggled in traditional settings.
See more original research from School Decision →