The top reported proficiency rate is 26% in English language arts. The lowest is 8% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Margaret Sheehy Elementary
Margaret Sheehy Elementary sits in Merced, a small city in the northern Central Valley undergoing significant change. The school serves kindergarten through sixth grade and has an enrollment of about five hundred students, with the vast majority qualifying for free or reduced-price meals. The student body is predominantly Hispanic, with smaller populations of Black, Asian, and multiracial students, and white students present in limited numbers.
Academic performance at Margaret Sheehy is a primary concern for any parent considering it. State testing data from 2024-2025 shows proficiency rates well below what the state expects. In English language arts, roughly one quarter to one third of students tested in grades three through four reached proficiency; that drops to around one quarter in grade five and below one fifth in grade six. Mathematics is considerably weaker. Third graders achieved roughly one third proficiency, fourth graders roughly one fifth, but fifth graders fell to single-digit proficiency, and sixth graders climbed only slightly to around one seventh proficiency. Science proficiency in grade five, the only grade tested, was below one tenth. Compared to other districts in Merced County, the school's overall proficiency index places it in the bottom quartile, meaning it performs lower than most peers in the region. Trend data for the current year only, with no prior-year comparison available, so it is not yet clear whether these results represent stable performance, improvement, or decline.
The school is part of the Merced City Elementary District, a district of eighteen schools that voters approved a substantial facilities bond in November 2024. That bond will fund modernization and safety upgrades across all schools over roughly the next decade and will raise property taxes for residents. The district is also in the midst of significant boundary and grade-configuration changes aimed at addressing overcrowding. Starting in the 2025-2026 school year, elementary school boundaries will shift. Starting the following year, sixth graders will move from elementary schools to middle school campuses. If Margaret Sheehy's address places it in a boundary that changes, a family could expect reassignment.
Merced itself is a tree-lined small city of mixed use, with a downtown core of locally owned shops, restaurants, and civic anchors around Main Street, plus surrounding residential neighborhoods. The city anchors on higher education through UC Merced and Merced College, healthcare through Mercy Medical Center, agriculture and food processing in the broader county, and government employment. The city is actively shaping growth through UC Merced's expansion and the coming California High-Speed Rail station, which will arrive in downtown and trigger reshaping of the Station Area Plan. That public investment and new transit infrastructure may reshape the housing market and quality of life in the coming years. Current housing prices in the Merced area are roughly one third to one half of California median home values, with rental costs lower than mortgage equivalents; homes and rentals are accessible relative to national benchmarks. The city has an extensive bike-path system, parks including Applegate Park and Zoo, and transit through Merced County Transit, Amtrak, and planned high-speed rail, though the main UC campus sits separated from downtown.
A parent evaluating Margaret Sheehy should begin by looking directly at those test results and understanding what support the school offers to students below proficiency, as the majority of the student body falls into that category. The district boundary changes will matter if the family lives in a zone that shifts. A parent may also want to ask about the school's instructional approach in literacy and mathematics, what supplemental programs exist, and how the school's recent facilities bond is being used. The low proficiency numbers raise real questions about learning outcomes and pace that merit direct conversation with school leadership.
See more original research from School Decision →