The top reported proficiency rate is 41% in English language arts. The lowest is 19% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Carl Smith Middle
Carl Smith Middle is a small six-through-eight middle school in Terra Bella, an agricultural community in Tulare County. The school serves a cohesive, economically challenged student body. Nearly all students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, and the enrollment is overwhelmingly Hispanic, with very few students of other racial backgrounds. Demographic data on English learners and students with individualized education plans were not available.
The school's academic results show meaningful weakness. In math, proficiency is low across the grade span, with sixth grade at its lowest point. Seventh-grade math improves somewhat, and eighth grade registers the highest proficiency on math assessments, though it remains well below state norms. English language arts results are stronger by comparison. Sixth grade shows modest proficiency, while seventh and eighth grades both report proficiency around the mid-range for the state, with eighth grade slightly ahead. A science assessment in eighth grade showed proficiency below math. On a social studies assessment from an earlier era, proficiency was very low.
Overall proficiency across tested subjects sits below the midpoint when compared to the other districts in Tulare County, which is the relevant peer group.
Terra Bella Union Elementary, the school's district, operates under the state's Community Schools Partnership Program. This means the school campus now hosts on-site counselors, social workers, and behavioral health services to support students. That program is active through the current school year, and the district maintains implementation plans for both its elementary school and Carl Smith Middle, signaling a commitment to wraparound student support.
The community itself is small and rural. Terra Bella is an unincorporated census-designated place built on agriculture; the nation's second-largest pistachio processor operates its main facilities there and has been expanding. The housing stock is aging, with a substantial share of mobile homes, and most residents rent. The population has been flat or declining over recent years. Median age skews young, reflecting the demographic of working families. Civic anchors are modest: the branch library is housed at the middle school itself as a joint facility with the Tulare County Library system. There is bus transit to neighboring Porterville but limited walkability within Terra Bella; most residents drive.
Housing values in the zip code have grown modestly in recent years. An earlier attempt to pass a school district bond measure to repair aging facilities, modernize classrooms, and bring buildings up to code failed at the ballot, so planned capital improvements did not receive that funding.
A parent evaluating this school would be choosing a small, tight-knit middle school serving a predominantly low-income, Hispanic farm community with meaningful academic headwinds. The addition of community school supports is a concrete asset. A parent may want to look into the school's trajectory and what specific academic interventions are in place, given the proficiency levels. The school's strengths relative to its context and the student population it serves are a question worth exploring with the school directly.
See more original research from School Decision →