The top reported proficiency rate is 32% in English language arts. The lowest is 21% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Bill Metz Elementary School
Bill Metz Elementary School serves grades two through five in Monte Vista, a small agricultural town in Colorado’s San Luis Valley. The school is part of the Monte Vista School District No. C-8. It is a regular public school, not a charter or magnet.
The student body is heavily Hispanic, with a substantial share of white students and small numbers of Native American, Black, and multiracial students. The school serves a population where a large majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which is consistent with the community’s economic profile. Monte Vista itself is a compact town with a traditional downtown core, anchored by the Carnegie Public Library, a national wildlife refuge, and seasonal events like the Crane Festival and Ski-Hi Stampede. The largest employment sectors are educational services, professional and technical services, and public administration. The town’s population has been declining slightly in recent years, and no major new housing developments were identified in public sources. Housing values in the area are well below state and national benchmarks, which makes the community more affordable than many Colorado towns.
Academically, state testing results show that proficiency rates in math, English language arts, and science are below levels that most families would consider strong. In math, roughly one in five students scored proficient or above. In English language arts, about one in three students did. In science, tested in grade five alone, about three in ten students scored proficient or above. Viewed against the other school districts in Rio Grande County, Bill Metz Elementary’s overall proficiency across tested subjects and grades falls in the top quartile. That context matters: there are only three districts in the county, and the range of performance is narrow. The school sits at the higher end of that small set, but in absolute terms its results point to a setting where many students are not yet meeting grade-level expectations.
Participation rates on the state assessments were above the minimum threshold, so the results reflect a broad cross-section of the tested grades. The school’s grade span means there is no graduation rate to report; that measure does not apply here. Chronic absenteeism data was not available in the provided materials.
The district brief turned up no recent parent-relevant changes, such as boundary adjustments or new program launches, from publicly available information. The school appears stable in its offerings and operations. No information on program offerings, staffing ratios, or course access was included in the data. A parent looking into the school may want to ask directly about class sizes, enrichment opportunities, and what support structures exist for students who are below grade level in reading or math.
Monte Vista’s setting is rural and economically modest. Housing is relatively affordable compared to the rest of Colorado, and the commute times are short for a small town. The school itself is located on Second Street in the town, not on a remote campus. For a family considering the area, the decision about Bill Metz Elementary will hinge less on standout academic performance and more on whether the school’s fit with their child’s needs aligns with the community’s character—a small, agricultural valley town with a tight-knit feel, a district that is among the better performers locally, and a student population where the economic challenges are real and reflected in the test results.
See more original research from School Decision →