The top reported proficiency rate is 24% in English language arts. The lowest is 15% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Johnson Elementary School
Johnson Elementary School is one of the elementary schools serving the Montrose County School District Re-1J, located in the city of Montrose in western Colorado. Serving students from pre-kindergarten through fifth grade, it is a regular public school with an enrollment that makes it a mid-sized elementary within the district. The school sits outside of Montrose’s historic downtown core, on a campus that is part of the district’s distributed network of neighborhood schools.
The student body is diverse in its composition. The largest racial and ethnic groups are Hispanic and white, each representing roughly half of the student population, with a small share of students identifying as two or more races and a handful of students identifying as American Indian or Alaska Native or Black. A substantial share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which is an indicator of the economic context many families in the area navigate. Data on the share of students with disabilities and those classified as English learners was not available in the profile, so a parent wanting a fuller picture of the school’s special population supports may want to ask the school directly.
On state assessments administered in the 2024–25 school year, Johnson Elementary’s results sit in a range that families should examine closely. In math across grades three through five, the proportion of students scoring at a proficient or advanced level was below a quarter. In English language arts across those same grades, the rate was slightly higher but still under a third. In fifth-grade science, about a quarter of students scored at a proficient or advanced level. Taken together, the school’s overall proficiency index across tested subjects placed it in the bottom quartile relative to districts across Montrose County. This is a soft spot in the school’s academic profile. A family considering Johnson Elementary will want to understand what the school offers in terms of academic intervention, enrichment, and the specific approaches teachers use to move students toward proficiency.
The district is in the middle of a significant pedagogical change. Montrose County Re-1J is transitioning to a Mastery Learning system, which replaces traditional letter grades with proficiency scales that aim to reflect actual academic understanding rather than effort or behavior. This is being rolled out across all K–12 schools, and full adoption is targeted for the 2027–2028 school year. For families at Johnson Elementary, this means that how their child’s learning is assessed and communicated is changing. The district has also partnered with an external organization to overhaul its intervention systems and Multi-Tiered Systems of Support, with the stated goal of reducing over-identification for special education and improving equity for students with disabilities and those at risk. These are structural shifts that will affect how struggling students are identified and supported, and families whose children may need extra help should understand how these changes are unfolding at Johnson.
The school itself is located in Montrose, a city that functions as the county seat and an economic hub for the Uncompahgre Valley. Montrose has a historic downtown and a mix of residential neighborhoods and commercial corridors. The community has seen notable growth in recent years, driven by its relative affordability compared to other parts of Colorado and its proximity to outdoor recreation. The housing market reflects this demand, with home values and rents that are significant, though still below the statewide average. The city has invested in infrastructure, including a large recreation center and trail systems. The loss of a major manufacturing employer in 2021 was a setback for the local economy, but new commercial development has continued. For families, the broader Montrose context is one of a growing, increasingly connected regional hub where outdoor amenities and a lower cost of living than the Front Range draw new residents.
The district brief did not include specific information about programs or extracurricular offerings at Johnson Elementary, so a parent will want to ask the school about what is available in terms of art, music, physical education, before- and after-school care, and any specialized programs. The school serves only elementary grades, so there is no graduation rate to report, and state testing results cover only the tested grades.
For families weighing this school, the numbers are a key piece of the picture. Johnson Elementary serves a diverse and economically varied student body, and its assessment results suggest that many students are not yet reaching the state’s proficiency benchmarks. The district’s move to mastery-based grading and the overhaul of intervention systems are direct responses to that challenge. A family considering this school will want to talk to the principal and teachers about how those changes are showing up in the classroom, what support is available for students who are behind, and what a typical school day looks like for a child in each grade.
See more original research from School Decision →