The top reported proficiency rate is 56% in English language arts. The lowest is 45% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Cottonwood Elementary School
Cottonwood Elementary School serves students from kindergarten through fifth grade and sits within the Montrose County School District Re-1J, the public school system for the city of Montrose and the surrounding area. Montrose is the county seat of Montrose County and the second-largest city in western Colorado, functioning as an economic and transportation hub for the Uncompahgre Valley. The city has a historic downtown core with a visitor center, restaurants, and seasonal live music, but much of the residential and commercial fabric is low-density and auto-oriented, with many schools, including Cottonwood, located on separate campuses spread through neighborhoods rather than clustered downtown.
The school itself has a sizable enrollment, and the student body is predominantly white, with a substantial Hispanic share and small numbers of Asian, Black, and multiracial students. A significant portion of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, indicating a meaningful share of families with lower household incomes. Data on students with individualized education programs and English learners was not available in this profile, so a parent may want to ask the school directly about the level of special education and language support services.
On state assessments, Cottonwood’s students performed at a level that placed the school in the top quartile of schools within Montrose County when looking at combined proficiency across tested subjects. In English language arts, more than half of students scored proficient or advanced. In math, a smaller but still substantial share reached that benchmark. In science, tested only in fifth grade, roughly half of students scored proficient. By comparison with other schools in the county, Cottonwood stands out as a relatively strong performer, particularly in a district context where the county-level proficiency index for other schools was notably lower. The school had very high participation rates on all tests, so the results reflect nearly the entire student body.
Because Cottonwood serves only elementary grades, there is no graduation rate to report, and no course access data was available. The district is in the midst of a multi-year transition to a Mastery Learning system, which replaces traditional letter grades with proficiency scales that measure students’ actual understanding of defined learning goals. Full adoption is targeted for the 2027-2028 school year, so current and incoming families at Cottonwood will be part of this ongoing shift in how students are assessed and graded. The district has also partnered with an external organization to overhaul its intervention systems and Multi-Tiered Systems of Support, with the goal of reducing over-identification for special education and improving support for at-risk learners. Both changes are meaningful for families to understand, as they affect how academic progress is communicated and how struggling students are identified and helped.
Montrose itself has been growing, with its population increasing substantially over the past decade. The city has invested in public infrastructure including a large new recreation center and trail connections, and it remains relatively affordable compared to much of the rest of Colorado. The loss of a major manufacturing employer in 2021 was a setback for the local economy, but new commercial development has followed with public incentives. Home values and rents in the area are below the state average, making it a more accessible market than many Front Range communities. The typical commute in Montrose is short, and the city is bicycle-friendly with a trail system that connects key destinations. For a family considering the area, Cottonwood Elementary offers a school with consistently strong test results relative to other county schools, in a district undergoing deliberate pedagogical change, within a growing city that combines outdoor recreation access with a moderate cost of living.
See more original research from School Decision →