The top reported proficiency rate is 36% in English language arts. The lowest is 29% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on American Legacy Academy
American Legacy Academy is a public charter school in Windsor, Colorado, serving kindergarten through eighth grade. It is part of the Weld County Reorganized School District No. Re‑4, though as a charter it operates with its own governance and curriculum focus. The school sits in a town that has grown rapidly over the past two decades, with residential subdivisions spreading westward toward Interstate 25 and industrial parks anchored by manufacturers such as Vestas, Owens Illinois, and Hexcel. The median household income in Windsor is well above the regional average, and owner‑occupied housing makes up a substantial majority of units. Housing values in the local zip code are competitive with the state benchmark, and rents have edged upward recently, reflecting the area’s sustained demand.
The school enrolls about the size typical of an elementary‑through‑middle school in this grade band. The student body is predominantly white, with a notable share of Hispanic students and small numbers from other racial and ethnic groups. Data on students eligible for free or reduced‑price lunch, students with disabilities, and English learners were not available, so a parent may want to ask the school directly about the extent of economic diversity and the support structures in place for different learners. The grade span tapers sharply in the upper grades: kindergarten has the largest enrollment, and the numbers become much smaller by seventh and eighth grade. This pattern may reflect the school’s relative newness or the tendency of families to transition to other middle schools in the district; it is worth understanding what the school’s long‑term enrollment plan looks like for the older grades.
On state assessments administered in the 2024‑25 school year, the school’s overall proficiency index—a combined measure across math, reading, and science—landed in the top quartile when compared with other districts in Weld County. In math, roughly a third of tested students scored at the proficient or advanced level, and reading proficiency was at a similar level. Science results for fifth graders were a bit lower. The eighth‑grade science score was suppressed, so no reliable comparison is possible there. By county standards, the school’s academic results place it among the stronger performers in the region, though the absolute proficiency rates leave room for growth. Because the school does not serve high school grades, there is no graduation rate to report; families interested in the full K‑12 trajectory will want to look at the secondary options their students would feed into, including the district’s high schools and the CTE pathways that Weld Re‑4 has recently expanded.
The district itself has been investing in facilities and curriculum. A bond approved in 2022 is funding safety upgrades, the rebuild of two elementary schools, and additions at middle and high schools, all while holding the tax rate steady. The district also adopted a Graduate Profile that frames skills like creating, evaluating, advocating, and participating, and it has added career‑technical courses in cybersecurity, welding, and health sciences. As a charter school within this district, American Legacy Academy may or may not participate directly in those district‑wide initiatives; a parent should clarify how the school’s programming aligns with the district’s strategic plan.
For a family considering American Legacy Academy, the picture is one of a charter school in a growing, relatively prosperous town, with academic proficiency that stands out favorably against county peers. The missing pieces—economic need data, special education and English learner counts, and the small middle‑grade enrollment—are areas worth investigating further. The school’s early‑through‑middle focus means it is only one step in a longer educational path, so understanding the transition to high school is important. The community context of Windsor offers a suburban environment with a strong industrial base, expanding parks and trails, and a downtown that retains a small‑town feel despite rapid growth.
See more original research from School Decision →