The top reported proficiency rate is 65% in Science. The lowest is 51% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Candlewood Lake Elementary School
Candlewood Lake Elementary School serves children from pre-kindergarten through fifth grade in a community experiencing substantial residential growth and change. The school itself is new, having opened in 2023 after a major consolidation that merged two older elementary buildings into a single modern facility. This represents a significant shift in how Brookfield's youngest students are educated, and families with early elementary children will want to understand both the school's current academic standing and the infrastructure context around it.
Academically, Candlewood Lake Elementary shows mixed performance across grade levels and subjects. In English language arts, the school demonstrates strength in the upper grades, particularly in fourth and fifth grade, where proficiency is above the midpoint. Third grade lags notably in ELA, sitting below the midpoint. Mathematics presents a steeper challenge. Fourth grade performs reasonably in math, but third and fifth grade proficiency fall below the state's proficiency threshold, with fifth grade in particular showing weaker performance. Science results, available only for fifth grade, are solid. Across all tested subjects and grades combined, the school sits in the bottom quartile when compared to other schools within the region. This positioning suggests the school faces genuine academic headwinds, particularly in elementary mathematics, that parents may want to explore further with the school's administration as their child approaches these grades.
Participation in state assessments is strong and consistent, with nearly all tested students engaging in the assessment, which means the reported results reflect what is actually happening with instruction at the school. Student demographics show a predominantly white enrollment with meaningful Hispanic and Asian populations. About one-quarter of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, indicating moderate economic diversity within a district that is broadly affluent. Data on English learners and students with individualized education plans was not available, so families with students in those categories may want to ask the school directly about support services.
Brookfield itself is a residential suburb and commuter community roughly an hour northeast of New York City, experiencing steady growth, particularly around its downtown area at Four Corners. Housing costs are above the state average and well above the national benchmark, reflecting the town's position as an upscale Fairfield County suburb. The town is car-dependent, with development scattered across multiple centers rather than walkable neighborhoods. The consolidation of elementary schools into Candlewood Lake represents a deliberate bet by the district on a modern, centralized facility rather than neighborhood-based schools.
Parents considering this school should weigh that the building itself is new and designed with environmental themes, but academic results, especially in early elementary mathematics, lag regional peers. Asking about the school's specific plans to address math proficiency in third grade, and what reading interventions and math supports exist for students below grade level, would help any parent make a more informed choice. The broader district has implemented a later start time at the high school for adolescent health reasons and has faced consecutive property tax increases, factors that shape the overall cost of living in this community.
See more original research from School Decision →