The top reported proficiency rate is 32% in English language arts. The lowest is 28% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Carbone School/east Haven Academy
Carbone School, which houses the East Haven Academy magnet program for grades 1 through 8, serves a student population of about 350 spread across the lower elementary and middle grades. The school is located in East Haven, a coastal residential town just east of New Haven with a mixed demographic makeup, substantial Latino and Italian-American heritage, and a car-dependent, suburban character centered on I-95, Route 1, and scattered commercial corridors rather than a dense pedestrian core.
The school's academic results show a pattern that a parent examining the data should understand clearly. In math, proficiency rates across tested grades range from roughly a quarter at the third-grade level to about one-third in the fourth and sixth grades. By seventh and eighth grade, math proficiency holds steady around one-third. Reading proficiency is somewhat stronger: fourth graders show nearly two in five at proficiency, but third graders and the upper middle grades show notably lower proficiency rates. Science results, where Connecticut tests grades 5 and 8, had their proficiency data suppressed for public reporting, though scale scores were recorded. Taken together across all tested subjects and grades, the school's overall proficiency index places it below the midpoint among the South Central Connecticut Planning Region's districts. This is ground a parent needs to see plainly: this school's achievement levels are not where the strongest district performers sit. The question then becomes whether this reflects broader district capacity, the specific student population served, resource allocation, or other factors a parent would want to explore directly with school leadership.
Demographically, the school mirrors the town's composition. About two-thirds of students are white, with a substantial Latino population at roughly one-quarter of enrollment and smaller African American and multiracial cohorts. Just under half of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, placing the school in a mixed-income serving context. Special education and English learner enrollment data were not made available in the source records. Attendance and discipline metrics were also absent from the public data.
The school operates as a regular public elementary and middle school within the East Haven School District, not as a standalone charter or fully independent magnet, and it shares its building or educational footprint as part of a district-level reorganization. The district recently consolidated its school structure, moving the East Haven Academy program from its standalone building into Joseph Melillo Middle School, a structural change that affects which building families' children attend going forward. At the secondary level, East Haven High School has expanded its career and technical offerings, including a new Advanced Manufacturing Lab and an Aviation Career Exploration Program drawing middle-school participants, but those pathways are not available at Carbone itself.
East Haven's housing market sits in the moderate range for Connecticut. Home values have appreciated modestly year over year. Rentals are available and active, reflecting the town's mix of owner-occupied Capes and Colonials and newer multifamily complexes near Main Street and the town center. The broader town context is one of steady, if contested, development: new residential projects are in proposal or planning stages, the Planning and Zoning Commission moved in 2025 to study affordable housing requirements amid developer activity, and the most consequential growth story is the proposed Tweed New Haven Airport expansion, a major infrastructure project on the East Haven/New Haven line that carries local debate over traffic, noise, and environmental impact alongside promises of state funding for public safety infrastructure and protected annual payments to the town.
The district is making visible infrastructure and program investments. Rooftop solar photovoltaic systems were installed across several schools, including Grove Tuttle Elementary, commissioned in June 2025. These are long-term energy and educational infrastructure choices. The district also recently navigated a school consolidation, which reorganized how students move through buildings as they progress from primary through middle grades.
For a family considering Carbone School or East Haven Academy, the read is this: the school serves a working and middle-income, mixed-racial community in a suburban town with real economic vitality and proximity to New Haven's institutional anchors, but the current state testing results place it below the center of the region's district performance. Whether this reflects recent transitions, student population factors, or resource constraints is not apparent from the data alone, and warrants a conversation with school and district leaders about their current priorities, any support or intervention strategies underway, and how they characterize the school's trajectory. The town itself is stable, navigating growth and development pressures in a way families planning to stay long-term will want to watch. The school is neither a destination school within the district nor a weak outlier; it is a middle-band performer serving its immediate community.
See more original research from School Decision →