The top reported proficiency rate is 67% in Science. The lowest is 59% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Orchard Hills School
Orchard Hills School serves early grades from pre-K through grade five in Milford, a mid-sized coastal Connecticut city with a walkable downtown anchored by one of New England's longest town greens, distinct residential neighborhoods, coastal villages, and about seventeen miles of shoreline. The school enrolls a modest-sized cohort for its grade band, with a student body that is predominantly white and includes smaller shares of Hispanic, Asian, Black, and multiracial students. Roughly one in five students qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch.
Test results from spring 2025 show performance that varies by grade and subject. In grade three, students performed well in math and moderately well in English language arts. Grade four proficiency declined notably in both subjects. By grade five, English language arts and science results improved substantially, while math performance remained lower. Across all tested grades and subjects, the school's overall proficiency position sits above the midpoint compared to other districts in South Central Connecticut Planning Region.
The specific patterns worth noting: third graders showed stronger outcomes; fourth grade appears to be a transition point where proficiency drops across both tested subjects; and fifth graders regained ground in reading and science, though math proficiency stayed modest. This grade-by-grade variation is common and may reflect curriculum demands or instructional factors particular to each grade level. Parents might ask the school directly about fourth-grade supports and math instruction across the grades to understand these patterns better.
Orchard Hills sits within the Milford School District, which is navigating substantial change. In May 2026 the Board of Education adopted a long-range facilities master plan that will close two elementary schools (Calf Pen Meadow and Meadowside) and one middle school, moving from eight to six elementary buildings over roughly the next two decades. The plan reflects aging facilities and declining enrollment and carries an estimated cost in the range of a major capital investment to be spread across that period, a spending scale that will influence property taxes durably. Pumpkin Delight Elementary recently completed a comprehensive renovation adding modern learning spaces, so the district is actively refreshing some buildings while consolidating others. School budgets have faced repeated reductions from town finance officials over recent years as board of education requests have been trimmed at the budget approval stage, a constraint that affects programming, staffing, and class-size decisions.
The broader Milford community is experiencing sustained downtown development with new market-rate housing and mixed-use projects near the green, anchored by the Metro-North train station and a robust park system including Silver Sands State Park with beach and shoreline access. The city's economy blends retail, healthcare, education, and light manufacturing.
For families in or considering Orchard Hills' attendance area, the key landscape includes solid early-grade performance, a notable dip in fourth grade that warrants understanding, improving results by fifth grade, a school district managing significant long-term infrastructure and enrollment transitions, and a town with active downtown revitalization and residential appeal. The facilities consolidation plan is a material consideration for families thinking about school stability and the district's trajectory over the next decade and beyond.
See more original research from School Decision →