The top reported proficiency rate is 12% in English language arts. The lowest is 10% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Augusta Lewis Troup School
Augusta Lewis Troup School serves kindergarten through eighth grade in New Haven's Edgewood neighborhood, part of a district that has undergone significant curriculum shifts in recent years. The school's enrollment spans the full elementary and early middle grade range, with a student body that reflects New Haven's diversity: roughly half the enrollment is Black, a substantial share is Hispanic, and smaller numbers of Asian, white, and multiracial students attend. A very large majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, placing this school in a neighborhood with limited household wealth.
The school's academic performance shows substantial challenges. In math, proficiency rates range from single digits in grades four through eight, with a low in grade five. Grade three math proficiency is somewhat higher, but still modest. English language arts shows a similar pattern: proficiency is very low in grades three, four, and eight, and where data are suppressed for confidentiality, the scale scores suggest performance well below state benchmarks. Science results are also suppressed, though available scale scores again suggest below-grade-level performance. Across tested grades and subjects, the school's overall proficiency falls in the bottom quartile when compared to other districts in the South Central Connecticut Planning Region.
These numbers matter because they reflect student learning outcomes in the here-and-now. Parents should know what they are choosing: a school where most students are not yet meeting grade-level standards, and where the academic need is substantial.
The district did implement a major shift in reading instruction in 2023, moving to a phonics-based science-of-reading approach and adopting a single K-6 core curriculum so that students in the same grade now receive the same lessons rather than divergent instruction school to school. This was a deliberate reset in how the system teaches literacy, and the district has reported early improvements in reading growth rates. These gains appear to be emerging, which means families might see reading instruction differently framed than in prior years, though time is needed to know whether the shift will move proficiency numbers substantially.
The district faces budget pressures. It began the school year with significant unfunded obligations, unfilled vacant positions, and risks of larger class sizes or layoffs in coming years. A 2023 teachers' contract caps standard class size at twenty-six for kindergarten through second grade and twenty-seven for grades three through twelve until 2026, which provides some structural protection. Still, budget tightness is a real constraint on resources.
Augusta Lewis Troup is situated in New Haven, a city experiencing active residential growth and cultural reinvestment around downtown, the New Haven Green, and Yale University. The neighborhood served by this school is part of the broader city fabric of distinct residential areas, walkable blocks, and mixed-income households. Housing values in the zip code are moderate relative to the state and national benchmarks. The school serves the neighborhood families who live in its attendance area, not a selective or choice-based population.
A parent choosing this school should expect a neighborhood school with substantial academic need, a newly reformed reading curriculum that is showing early promise, and tight district finances that may affect classroom conditions. The school is not a standout performer, and the proficiency data make that clear. For families whose alternatives are limited by geography or who believe they can support their child's learning outside school hours, or who are committed to neighborhood schooling, this is a school that exists in an under-resourced environment and would benefit from parental engagement. A parent may want to look further into what reading progress looks like for their child's specific grade and what additional supports are available in math and other subjects.
See more original research from School Decision →