The top reported proficiency rate is 81% in Science. The lowest is 65% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Peck Place School
Peck Place School is a small, public elementary school serving grades one through six in Orange, Connecticut, a affluent residential suburb west of New Haven. The school enrolls roughly 350 students in a community where the majority of families are white, a substantial share identify as Asian, and a small share qualify for free or reduced lunch. The student body reflects the town's generally stable, middle-to-upper-middle-class character.
In academic performance, the school shows uneven results across grades and subjects. In English language arts, fourth and fifth graders perform notably well, with a strong majority reaching proficiency. Third graders and sixth graders show lower proficiency rates. Mathematics results tell a similar story: fourth grade stands out, fifth grade lags, and third and sixth grades fall between. Science performance in fifth grade, the grade tested, is strong. The school's overall proficiency index places it in the top quartile among the county's school districts, though that aggregate masks meaningful grade-level variation. A reader should note that the third-grade numbers in particular might warrant a conversation with the school about how early literacy instruction, recently reformed under the state's Right to Read law, is taking hold. Across all grades, participation in state testing is nearly complete, and no apparent attendance or engagement barrier shows in the data.
The school operates within the Orange School District, a small preK through sixth-grade district serving the town's earliest learners. The district recently adopted a state-mandated, science-of-reading curriculum for kindergarten through third grade, a change that took effect in summer 2024 and is fully in place now. For families with children in those grades, this represents a structured, evidence-based shift in how reading is taught. The district also added a culturally responsive instruction coach—a permanent staffing addition meant to support teaching that reflects student diversity and strengthens school belonging.
Orange itself is a car-dependent, low-density suburb with a preserved historic town center but little walkable commercial core. Housing costs are well above state and national medians, placing homes and rentals out of reach for many families. The median household income runs above national levels. Postwar residential construction defines the town's physical form, though zoning rules have kept growth measured and preserved open space and working farms. The town green and community center form the civic anchor rather than a downtown district. For families with elementary-age children, the key structural fact is that Orange feeds into the separate Amity Regional School District for middle and high school, meaning students are bused north to Woodbridge from sixth grade onward.
A parent considering Peck Place should know its strengths: strong science instruction and solid overall county standing. They should also recognize its soft spots: third-grade literacy performance lags, and fifth-grade math proficiency sits below the school's fourth-grade peak, suggesting some grade-level unevenness worth exploring directly. The school's small enrollment and elementary-only span mean it is a tight, contained community, not a large or diverse learning environment. For families seeking a quiet, residential suburban setting with modest class sizes and established school culture, Peck Place fits that profile. For those wanting high, consistent performance across all grade levels, a parent may want to look into the school's literacy support systems and the grade-five math curriculum more deeply.
See more original research from School Decision →