The top reported proficiency rate is 40% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Stafford Elementary School
Stafford Elementary serves first through fifth grade in a school of a modest size for its grade band in the center of Stafford Springs, a mill-village downtown with a working-class, independent-business character in rural northeastern Connecticut. The school is a regular public elementary school operated by the Stafford School District.
The school's academic performance places it below the midpoint among districts in the Capitol Planning Region. Across tested subjects, less than half of students in grades three through five meet proficiency in English language arts or math. In third grade, proficiency stands in the low to mid-range in both subjects; fourth grade shows the highest performance of the three tested grades in math, though still below where it starts in second grade when aggregated. Fifth grade shows the lowest proficiency levels. Science testing occurred only in fifth grade, with a scaled score reported but the proficiency rate suppressed by the state, meaning the school participated fully but the count of proficient students was not disclosed. When proficiency is averaged across all tested grades and subjects, the school sits in the bottom quartile of county districts on overall proficiency.
The student body is racially and ethnically predominantly white, with roughly a tenth identifying as Hispanic and smaller representation of other groups. A substantial share of students, just under two-fifths, qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. Data on special education enrollment and English learner status were not reported, so the full picture of learning supports and specialized services available is incomplete.
The district itself operates under fiscal strain. Stafford has faced repeated failed budget referendums, creating prolonged uncertainty about spending and staffing. In spring and summer 2026, three sequential referendums failed before a budget ultimately passed. A town-wide property revaluation that took effect in October 2025 shifted the tax burden toward residential owners, since home values rose faster than commercial values. Residential tax bills rose substantially starting in July 2026, a lasting cost that families considering the district would weigh. These fiscal pressures directly affect school programs and staffing, and the district has signaled that budget cuts are real.
The district has adopted the Science of Reading as its approach to literacy instruction across elementary grades, a pedagogical shift that shapes classroom instruction. The school is also located on a separate campus rather than in the downtown Stafford Springs village core, near the library at 10 Levinthal Run.
Housing values in the 06076 zip code are modest relative to the state benchmark, and monthly mortgage estimates remain accessible, though affordability will shift with the tax revaluation now in place. A parent or resident may want to look into further detail with the school and district about current staffing levels, the timeline for budget recovery, and specific reading and math supports in place, given the proficiency data and ongoing fiscal volatility.
See more original research from School Decision →