The top reported proficiency rate is 14% in English language arts. The lowest is 6% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Smothers Es
Smothers Elementary School sits on Brooks Street in Northeast Washington, a regular public school in the District of Columbia Public Schools system serving pre-kindergarten through fifth grade. It is a small school by DCPS standards, with a pre-kindergarten program that makes up a substantial portion of the enrollment. The student body is predominantly Black, with a smaller Hispanic presence and very few students from other racial backgrounds. The school does not carry charter or magnet status; it is a neighborhood school operating within the traditional DCPS framework.
Academic results from the most recent state assessment cycle are low. In math, a small fraction of tested students in grades three through eight met or exceeded expectations. In English language arts, the share meeting that bar was higher but still well below what DCPS aims for. Science results from the prior assessment cycle showed proficiency in the lowest reported band, with nearly all tested fifth graders scoring below proficient. Participation in testing was strong, so the results reflect the student population rather than a testing gap. These are difficult numbers to encounter, and a parent considering Smothers may want to ask the school directly what academic supports and interventions are in place, how growth is measured for individual students, and what the school's improvement trajectory looks like over time. The data we received does not include multi-year trend information, so we cannot say whether these results represent a decline, a plateau, or the beginning of improvement.
Several categories of information that would help round out the picture are missing from what we received. Free-or-reduced-price lunch data was not reported, so we cannot characterize the economic profile of the student body from the data, though the surrounding community context offers some signal. Individualized education program rates and English learner rates were also absent. Discipline, staffing, attendance, and course access data were not provided. Title I status was not reported. These gaps mean the portrait here is thinner than a family would want when making a decision, and a conversation with school leadership would be the right next step.
The surrounding ZIP code gives a sense of the housing market a family would enter. Home values in this part of Washington sit well below the DC-wide benchmark and modestly below the national figure, and they have been declining over the past year. Rents are more affordable relative to many parts of the city, with rent-to-income costs that look manageable against national medians. Owning here is a different calculus; estimated monthly mortgage costs run well above local rents, and the price-to-income ratio is elevated. This is a corner of Washington where renting is materially cheaper than buying, which may matter to families weighing a move.
The broader locale is Washington itself, a city built around the federal government. The economy is anchored by federal employment, international institutions, associations, and lobbying firms, with a metro system connecting neighborhoods to downtown and to Maryland and Virginia suburbs. The school's Northeast location places it east of the Anacostia River in a part of the city that has historically seen less investment than the monumental core, though development has reached various neighborhoods across all quadrants in recent years.
At the district level, DCPS is operating under a five-year strategic plan called A Capital Commitment, running through 2028, with goals around academic success, student connection to school, and post-secondary readiness. Beginning in the current school year, DCPS has implemented a district-wide cell phone restriction tied to city legislation, limiting phone use during the school day across all schools. The district also recently expanded middle-grade capacity in Southeast Washington with a new addition at Leckie Education Campus, which may be relevant for families thinking ahead to the transition after fifth grade.
What the data shows is a small neighborhood elementary school serving a predominantly Black student body in an affordable-by-DC-standards but economically pressed section of Northeast Washington, with proficiency results that fall short of state expectations across all three tested subjects. Whether Smothers is the right fit depends on what a family finds in conversation with the school about its academic plan, its culture, and the supports it offers, because the publicly available data here leaves real questions open.
See more original research from School Decision →