The top reported proficiency rate is 54% in English language arts. The lowest is 32% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Providence Creek Academy Charter School
Providence Creek Academy is a charter school in Clayton, Delaware, serving kindergarten through eighth grade. It is its own charter district, which means the school and the district are effectively the same entity. Families considering this school should understand one thing above everything else: the school's charter is under formal review. In November 2025, the Delaware Charter School Accountability Committee released an initial report finding that Providence Creek Academy does not meet standards in academic performance, financial operations, governance, organization, and the success of its educational program. The charter is set to expire at the end of June 2026, and if the deficiencies are not addressed, the State Board of Education may begin revocation proceedings. This is the single most important fact a family weighing enrollment or a move into this area needs to weigh, and a parent may want to ask the school directly where things stand and what the corrective plan looks like.
On academic performance, the most recent state assessment results show a mixed picture. English language arts proficiency sits above the midpoint, with a majority of tested students reaching proficiency. Math is weaker, with fewer than half of tested students proficient. Science is the softest area, with roughly a third of tested students meeting the bar. Social studies results from the prior year were comparatively stronger across the tested elementary and middle grades. When placed against other districts in Kent County using the county comparison set, the school's overall proficiency index lands in the top quartile, which means its combined results across tested subjects and grades rank above most of its county peers. That is a genuine strength, even given the concerns raised in the accountability review.
The multi-year trend tells a more complicated story. Before the pandemic, English language arts proficiency at the school was quite strong, with well over half and sometimes closer to three-quarters of students proficient. Those numbers fell sharply in the years following the pandemic and have been climbing back gradually. The most recent year's results represent real recovery in English language arts, though still below pre-pandemic levels. Math followed a similar arc, dropping steeply after the pandemic and recovering slowly, with the latest results approaching but not yet matching where the school stood several years ago. A parent may want to look into what the school is doing to accelerate that recovery, particularly in math and science, where results remain lower.
The school serves a moderately sized student body across all nine grade levels, with roughly even distribution from kindergarten through middle school. The racial and ethnic composition is diverse: nearly half the students are white, about a third are Black, and a meaningful share identify as two or more races, with smaller Hispanic, Asian, and American Indian populations. Several data points that would help a family understand the school's student support picture are missing. Free and reduced-price lunch data was not reported, so the economic need of the student body is unclear. Special education enrollment figures and English learner counts are also missing. Without these, it is hard to assess how the school serves its most vulnerable students, and a parent may want to ask the school for that information directly.
Because Providence Creek Academy ends at eighth grade, there is no graduation rate to report. That gap reflects the grade band, not a missing result. There is also no chronic absenteeism data available, and no discipline or course-access data was provided. The school's Title I status was not reported. Participation rates for the most recent math, English, and science assessments were missing as well.
Clayton sits in Kent County, and the local housing market reflects a modest small-town Delaware community. Typical home values in the school's zip code run somewhat above the statewide benchmark and above the national level, with modest year-over-year appreciation. Rental data was not available. Mortgage rates remain elevated by recent historical standards, which affects affordability for families considering a move into the area. We looked for detail on Clayton's downtown, walkability, and Main Street businesses but found little substantive information, so we left that out rather than guess.
No program offerings, course access details, or staffing information was provided, so we cannot characterize the school's academic pathways, extracurriculars, or teacher profile. For a charter school under accountability review, these are exactly the kinds of details a family would want in hand. The academic results, while recovering and competitive within Kent County, exist alongside the governance and financial concerns flagged by the state. A family looking at this school should treat the accountability review as the central question, use the proficiency data as context for what the school does well and where it struggles, and ask the school for the missing economic, special education, and program information before making a decision.
See more original research from School Decision →