The top reported proficiency rate is 36% in English language arts. The lowest is 24% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Brick Mill Elementary School
Brick Mill Elementary School sits on Brick Mill Road in Middletown, Delaware, serving first through fifth graders as part of the Appoquinimink School District. It is a regular public school, not a charter or magnet, and it draws from a community that has transformed over the past two decades from a quiet agricultural crossroads into one of Delaware's fastest-growing suburban areas.
The school's enrollment sits in the mid-range for an elementary building its size. Its student body is racially diverse, with white and Black students each making up roughly a third of the population, Hispanic students close to a fifth, and smaller Asian and multiracial groups rounding it out. This is a school where children grow up alongside peers from a range of backgrounds, which some families value as a real-world social environment. The data does not include free-or-reduced-price lunch counts, English learner rates, or special education rates for this school, so the economic profile and the share of students needing language or learning support cannot be characterized here. A parent looking into those details would want to ask the school directly.
On state assessments, Brick Mill's current results show roughly a third of tested students reaching proficiency in English language arts and math, with science slightly below that and social studies lower still. Looking at the longer trend, the school's ELA and math proficiency were substantially higher in the mid-2010s, then dropped sharply after the pandemic disruption and have not returned to their earlier levels. The most recent year shows a small upward tick in ELA and a modest gain in math compared to the prior year. Against the comparison set of districts in New Castle County, Brick Mill's overall proficiency index sits above the midpoint, meaning it performs better than a meaningful share of its county peers, though it is not in the top tier. These are the numbers available. The proficiency picture is one of a school that has struggled to regain its pre-pandemic footing but shows signs of slow recovery. A parent may want to look into what the school and district are doing to accelerate that trend.
Because Brick Mill serves only elementary grades, there is no graduation rate, and that metric does not apply here. Chronic absenteeism data was not available in the provided information, nor were discipline, staffing, or course-access details. The school's listed extracurriculars are limited to drama offerings, which suggests a modest but focused activities menu for this age group. More information would likely be available through the school's website.
Middletown itself is a town in the midst of sustained growth. The historic downtown centers on the Four Corners intersection of Main Street and Broad Street, with Cochran Square serving as a civic memorial. The town hosts an annual Olde Tyme Peach Festival that draws large crowds. Outside the old core, the built environment is largely suburban and auto-dependent, with toll roads running along the edges and schools sitting on separated campuses. The town has attracted major commercial development, including an Amazon fulfillment center and a Christiana Care free-standing emergency department, which bring jobs to the area.
The Appoquinimink School District has been building new schools steadily to keep up with enrollment growth, opening Odessa High School, Crystal Run Elementary, and a rebuilt Everett Meredith Middle School in recent years. Each new school opening triggers feeder-pattern revisions, which means families in this district should expect that attendance boundaries may shift over time as the district adjusts to population changes.
The housing market around Brick Mill reflects that growth. Typical home values in the school's zip code run above both state and national benchmarks, and rents are similarly elevated relative to those comparisons. With current mortgage rates, the monthly cost of ownership is notably higher than renting, and the price-to-income ratio suggests that buying here requires a substantial income relative to national norms. This is a community where housing costs have risen with the area's desirability and expansion.
For a family considering Brick Mill, the picture is of a diverse elementary school in a rapidly growing suburban town, part of a district under constant pressure to expand and adapt. Academic results are below where they were several years ago but have begun to edge upward, and the school sits in the upper half of its county comparison set on proficiency. The surrounding area offers suburban convenience, a small historic downtown, and growing employment options, all at a housing cost that runs above state and national averages.
See more original research from School Decision →