The top reported proficiency rate is 33% in English language arts. The lowest is 8% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Shue-medill Middle School
Shue-Medill Middle School sits on Capitol Trail in Newark, Delaware, serving grades six through eight as part of the Christina School District. The school draws from a community shaped by the University of Delaware, which dominates local employment and gives the city its college-town character. Main Street runs alongside the campus and serves as the primary commercial and social corridor, with student-oriented businesses and established residential neighborhoods radiating outward. Outside the downtown-campus core, most residents drive to work, and the surrounding area has transitioned from farmland to housing developments over the years, though open farmland remains just across the state lines in Maryland and Pennsylvania.
The student body is sizable for a middle school, with enrollment distributed fairly evenly across the three grade levels. The racial and ethnic composition reflects a genuinely mixed community: Black students make up the largest single group, followed by white and Hispanic students, with smaller shares of multiracial and Asian students. The school does not report free-or-reduced-price lunch figures, nor does it share Individualized Education Program or English learner counts, so the publicly available picture of economic disadvantage and special populations is incomplete. A parent looking for that context would need to ask the school directly.
On state assessments, Shue-Medill's results are modest and have been softening over the past decade. English language arts proficiency has drifted down from the mid-thirties in the mid-2010s to the high twenties and low thirties in recent years, with the most recent results showing a slight recovery. Math proficiency followed a similar arc, falling from the high twenties into the teens before ticking upward again in the latest round. Science proficiency is notably low, with only a small fraction of tested students reaching proficiency. Social studies results, reported separately by grade, show somewhat stronger performance in sixth grade than in eighth. Taken together, the school sits below the midpoint among districts in New Castle County on an overall proficiency index, a position consistent with the trend data rather than a one-year dip.
No graduation rate applies here, since the school does not serve high school grades, and that metric is not part of this school's profile. Discipline data, course access, staffing, and attendance figures were not available in the provided materials, so those dimensions of school climate cannot be characterized from what is on the page. Program offerings were also not reported, which limits the picture of what extracurricular or specialized academic options exist beyond the standard curriculum.
Housing in the school's zip code runs above both the state and national benchmarks for typical home values, and rents have been rising at a faster clip than home prices recently. The estimated monthly mortgage on a typical home in the area sits above the typical rent by a modest margin, and rent absorbs close to a third of median household income. For families considering a move into the attendance zone, the housing market is relatively expensive compared with much of the state, reflecting Newark's desirability as a university-adjacent community with commuter rail access via SEPTA and Amtrak on the Northeast Corridor. The Christina School District is also undergoing a property tax restructuring following a county-wide reassessment. Under Delaware's Title 14, the district plans to raise total tax receipts while reducing the nominal tax rate, a change that will reshape what homeowners pay annually and is worth understanding before committing to a purchase.
What Shue-Medill offers is a regular public middle school experience in a diverse, university-anchored community with good transit connections and established neighborhoods. The academic results are a soft spot, with proficiency rates that have been declining over time and remain below the county midpoint, though the most recent data shows tentative improvement in both reading and math. A parent evaluating this school may want to look into the reasons behind the science results in particular and ask about what support structures and program offerings the school provides, since those details were not available in the data reviewed.
See more original research from School Decision →