The top reported proficiency rate is 20% in Social studies. The lowest is 6% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Downie (carrie) Elementary School
Downie (Carrie) Elementary School sits on Delaware Street in New Castle, a small historic riverfront city a few miles south of Wilmington. The school serves kindergarten through fifth grade as part of the Colonial School District. It is a regular public school, not a charter or magnet, and its enrollment is modest for an elementary building, with students spread fairly evenly across the six grade levels.
The student body reflects the community around it. Black students make up the largest share, followed by white and Hispanic students in nearly equal proportions. A smaller group of students identify as two or more races. The school's racial and ethnic mix is more varied than many single-neighborhood elementaries, which gives children a peer environment that mirrors a genuinely multiracial small city. Several pieces of demographic information the state often reports were not available here, including free- or reduced-price lunch counts, English learner status, and special education enrollment. A parent evaluating student support would want to ask the school directly about those figures, since they help explain how the school allocates resources.
Academic results on the Smarter Balanced assessment in the most recent year were low in both core subjects. Math proficiency sat well below the state midpoint, and English language arts was similarly depressed. Science results, tested in a narrower grade band, were lower still. Social studies, reported on a different assessment cycle for fourth grade, showed a somewhat higher share of students meeting the proficiency bar, though still below what most schools in the county would consider strong. When measured against districts in New Castle County on an overall proficiency index, Downie lands in the bottom quartile. That places it among the lower-performing schools in a county that contains some of Delaware's highest-scoring districts.
The trend data gives context for these numbers. Before the pandemic, ELA proficiency at Downie was several times higher than it is now, and math was meaningfully stronger as well. Both subjects dropped sharply during and after the disruption. Math has shown a slight upward drift in the years since, while ELA has stayed flat at the lower level. This is a school whose academic standing fell hard and has not yet recovered. The data does not tell us why, but the pattern is clear enough that a family considering the school should ask about the specific supports and interventions now in place.
Because Downie is an elementary school, there is no graduation rate, and that gap in the data simply reflects the grade band served. Chronic absenteeism and discipline figures were also not available. The school's Title I status, which often signals whether a school receives federal funding tied to poverty levels, was not reported in the data we received. These are the kinds of gaps a parent can fill in with a phone call to the front office.
New Castle as a place is distinctive. The city is built around a historic common green laid out during the Dutch colonial period, with cobblestone streets, brick buildings dating to the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, and a National Historic Landmark District at its core. Civic life centers on that compact, walkable grid, with the old Court House, several historic churches, and the riverfront pier anchoring the area. Growth is limited by the city's preservation identity and its small footprint, so the neighborhood around the school has a settled, older-suburb character rather than a rapidly changing one. Publicly reported sources note that no major new housing developments have surfaced in recent searches, and the city's population has held relatively stable.
Housing in the school's zip code is affordable compared with both the state and national benchmarks. Home values sit below the Delaware median, and rents are moderate. The estimated monthly mortgage on a typical home is higher than typical rent, which tilts the area toward renters and first-time buyers rather than move-up purchasers. For a family weighing cost of living alongside school quality, this is a place where housing is accessible but the academic outcomes at this particular school warrant a closer conversation before enrolling.
See more original research from School Decision →