The top reported proficiency rate is 66% in Science. The lowest is 54% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Manatee Elementary School
Manatee Elementary sits on Manatee Road in the southeastern Naples area, serving children from pre-kindergarten through fifth grade in Collier County Public Schools. The school draws a predominantly Hispanic student body, with Black students making up the next largest share and white students a smaller fraction. A substantial majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, placing this school among higher-poverty elementary campuses. Data on English learner enrollment and students with IEPs was not available in the records provided.
On Florida's statewide FAST assessments, results from the most recent tested year show a mixed picture across grade levels. In math, third and fifth graders came in right around half proficient, while fourth graders performed noticeably stronger. ELA followed a similar shape: third grade came in just below half proficient, fourth grade climbed meaningfully higher, and fifth grade landed just above the halfway mark. Fifth grade science was the strongest single result, with roughly two-thirds of students scoring proficient on the Florida Statewide Science Assessment. Multi-year trend data was not available, so it is not possible to say whether these numbers have been improving or holding steady. A parent wondering about the trajectory of academic growth here would want to ask the school directly. Comparison data relative to other schools within Collier County was not available because the county has only one public school district, making a within-county district comparison statistically inapplicable.
The district itself has been through several substantive changes worth knowing about. Beginning with the 2023-24 school year, Collier adopted a structured, explicit phonics program for the earliest grades, a shift toward what is broadly called science-of-reading instruction. For a school like Manatee, which starts at pre-kindergarten, this curriculum change is directly relevant to how the youngest children are being taught to read. Voters also renewed a tax-neutral referendum in late 2024, which publicly reported accounts indicate redirects existing millage from capital to operating funds without a tax increase, sustaining funding for teacher pay through at least 2029. That kind of budget stability provides some assurance for families weighing whether the district will maintain staffing levels.
The housing market in the zip code around Manatee Elementary is expensive by both state and national benchmarks, with typical home values well above Florida's statewide median. Values have come down modestly over the past year, though they remain high in absolute terms. Rents in the area are also elevated, running substantially above what typical household income would suggest is comfortable. By the affordability ratios in the data, buying or renting near this school is a real financial stretch for families without significant income or equity. This matters more here than in many elementary school zones because the student population shows a large share qualifying for subsidized meals, suggesting that the families whose children attend Manatee Elementary are not necessarily the same families driving the local housing market.
Naples more broadly, as publicly reported sources describe it, is a Gulf-coast city with a walkable historic core centered on Fifth Avenue South and Third Street South, cultural venues including Artis-Naples and Gulfshore Playhouse, and a strong identity built around waterfront access and upscale amenities. Manatee Elementary's address on Manatee Road places it in a more inland, southeastern portion of the Naples area rather than in that historic downtown core, though the school's specific neighborhood character was not further described in the available records.
Programs data for Manatee Elementary was not provided, so details about any after-school, enrichment, or specialized programs the school may offer are not available here. Attendance and chronic absenteeism figures were also absent. Families considering this school would benefit from asking about both.
See more original research from School Decision →