The top reported proficiency rate is 43% in English language arts. The lowest is 25% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on New Beginnings - Naples
New Beginnings - Naples is a public alternative school operated by Collier County Public Schools, serving students in grades two through eight on Estey Avenue in Naples. Its enrollment is very small, a characteristic common to alternative school settings, and that smallness shapes nearly everything about the experience here.
Because this is a designated alternative school, the standard frame for evaluating a K-8 campus does not apply cleanly. Alternative schools typically serve students who have faced barriers in traditional school settings, whether behavioral, academic, or circumstantial, and the population at New Beginnings reflects that: a substantial share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, and the student body is predominantly Hispanic and Black. Data on English learners and students with IEPs were not available in what was provided.
State testing results from Florida's FAST assessments are partially reported and partially suppressed, with several grade-level results withheld, likely because the groups are too small for public reporting under state privacy rules. Where results are reported, math and ELA proficiency in the fifth and sixth grade cohorts sits well below majority proficiency, while the seventh grade cohort shows markedly stronger results in both subjects. The fifth grade science assessment also shows a minority of students scoring proficient. These figures are worth discussing directly with the school, because at this enrollment size, a handful of students can shift a grade-level result dramatically in either direction, and the numbers do not tell you much about instructional quality on their own. A parent wanting a fuller picture should ask the school how it tracks individual student progress over time and what academic supports are in place.
No program offerings, staffing ratios, attendance data, or discipline data were provided, so those dimensions of the school's environment cannot be described here.
The broader Collier County Public Schools district has made a few moves relevant to families weighing their options. In late 2024, voters renewed a tax-neutral referendum that shifts a portion of capital funds to operating funds without a tax increase, publicly reported to sustain teacher pay, arts programs, and athletics through 2029. The district also adopted a structured phonics curriculum starting in 2023-24 for early grades, a science-of-reading approach, along with new reading-support curriculum at the middle level. Whether and how those initiatives reach New Beginnings specifically is not something this data can answer.
Naples itself is a Gulf-coast city with a strong upscale character in its historic core, where Old Naples' walkable streets, galleries, and beach access give the area a distinct village feel. Publicly reported sources describe the downtown spine along Fifth Avenue South and Third Street South as the social and civic center, with cultural venues including Gulfshore Playhouse and the von Liebig Art Center nearby, and Cambier Park hosting free weekly concerts. The housing market here is expensive, with home values running above state and national benchmarks, though values have softened modestly over the past year. Rents are also high relative to typical household income, a pressure many families with children in alternative programs are already managing.
New Beginnings is not a school a family would choose for a typical academic pathway or program breadth. It exists to serve students who need a different environment than a conventional school provides. If your child has been referred or is considering this setting, the questions worth asking the school directly are what the structure of a typical day looks like, how reintegration into a traditional school is supported, and what counseling or social-emotional resources are available on site.
See more original research from School Decision →