The top reported proficiency rate is 55% in Math. The lowest is 47% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Mcdonald Elementary School
McDonald Elementary sits on West Pruett Road in Seffner, a census-designated place in eastern Hillsborough County that reads as suburban in form but still carries traces of its older, semi-rural character. Live oaks, former strawberry farm land, and newer subdivisions share the same streets. The school serves pre-kindergarten through fifth grade as a regular public school within the Hillsborough district.
The student body is sizeable for an elementary school, drawing a genuinely mixed population. White students make up the largest share, followed by Hispanic students, then Black students, with smaller groups across other categories. A large majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, meaning the school serves a community where economic resources are stretched for most families. Data on English learners and students with IEPs was not available in what was provided, so parents with children in those categories will want to ask the school directly.
On Florida's FAST assessments, the picture is mixed and parents should look at it with some care. In math, third-grade proficiency falls well below half of students, but by fifth grade the share reaching proficiency rises substantially and sits comfortably above the majority. ELA follows a similar arc, with third grade coming in below half and fifth grade reaching just over half of students. Fifth-grade science lands just under half proficient. The upward movement across grade levels within a single year is worth noting, though these are cross-sectional snapshots rather than the same students tracked over time. Multi-year trend data was not available, so there is no basis here to characterize whether results are improving or declining. A parent may want to ask the school what it is doing in the early grades, particularly third-grade reading, where the numbers are weakest. No comparison against other Hillsborough County schools was possible because the comparison set contained only a single district.
The school has no magnet designation and no program offerings data was provided, so specific enrichment tracks, arts programs, or special curricula cannot be described here. Title I status was listed as not reported.
The surrounding community in Seffner is car-dependent and organized around highway corridors near the I-4 and I-75 interchange rather than a walkable center. Publicly reported information describes the area's economy as shaped by warehousing, logistics, retail, and trades, with an Amazon distribution operation and national retailers among the visible employers. Civic anchors include a county branch library, community parks, recreation centers, and a sports complex, clustered near the Kingsway Road corridor rather than any traditional downtown.
On housing, the local market is priced close to the Florida statewide median and slightly below the national median, with values having edged down modestly in the past year. Rents have held roughly flat. New single-family construction from national builders continues to bring inventory to the area, reflecting Seffner's role in Tampa's ongoing eastward residential expansion. The market has cooled from its recent peak, with homes taking longer to sell.
Two district-level developments are relevant to any family choosing or already enrolled in a Hillsborough school. Hillsborough voters approved a property tax increase in late 2024, running through mid-2029, that adds a meaningful annual cost for homeowners and directs those funds toward teacher and staff pay supplements. Separately, the district carried out a significant boundary rezoning for the 2024-2025 school year that affected a large number of schools and potentially moved many students to different assignments. Families new to the area should confirm their attendance zone directly with the district, since those lines may have shifted recently.
McDonald Elementary is a neighborhood school serving a majority lower-income, diverse community in a growing suburban corridor. Its strongest academic numbers appear in the upper elementary grades, while early-grade proficiency, particularly in reading, is an area to watch and discuss further with the school.
See more original research from School Decision →