The top reported proficiency rate is 56% in Math. The lowest is 48% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Umatilla Middle School
Umatilla Middle School serves grades six through eight in the small Lake County city of Umatilla, situated roughly forty miles northwest of Orlando near the edge of the Ocala National Forest. It is a regular public school within the Lake County Schools district, sitting on East Lake Street just a short walk from the downtown core but on its own campus rather than embedded in the commercial strip along State Road 19.
The school draws a student body that is predominantly white, with Hispanic students making up the next largest share and smaller numbers of students identifying as Black, multiracial, or other backgrounds. Close to half of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which reflects the town's working-class and mixed-income character. Data on English learners and students with IEPs was not available in the materials provided, so a parent interested in those services would want to ask the school directly.
On Florida's FAST assessments, math proficiency sits in the mid-fifties range across the grades tested, and the eighth-grade science assessment lands in a similar band. ELA proficiency across all three tested grade levels comes in just under or just at the halfway mark, meaning roughly half of students are meeting the state's proficiency standard in reading and writing. These results are not strong by statewide comparison, and a parent thinking carefully about academic readiness for high school should ask the school what supports are in place for students who are not yet at grade level, particularly in literacy. Multi-year trend data was not available, so it is not possible to say from this data whether those numbers have been improving or holding steady.
No program offerings, course access, or extracurricular data were provided, so this section of the picture is genuinely thin. A family would need to contact the school or the district directly to understand what elective pathways, enrichment options, or clubs are available during these middle years.
The broader community context shapes who enrolls here. Umatilla is a car-dependent, semi-rural small town that publicly identifies itself as a gateway community to the Ocala National Forest. It has high homeownership, an older demographic that skews toward retirees, and a compact downtown with working commercial buildings but limited pedestrian-scale amenities. Publicly reported information indicates that residential construction has expanded in recent years through developments like Magnolia Pointe, meaning the town and potentially the school are absorbing new families, though enrollment growth from that has not yet stabilized into a clear trend visible in the data here.
Housing in the area comes in below the Florida statewide median, which makes this a relatively accessible market by Florida standards. Mortgage rates and carrying costs are consistent with the current national environment.
At the district level, Lake County voters in 2022 renewed a property-tax measure that funds school safety officers, nurses, and mental health staff including counselors, psychologists, and social workers across the district. A second, broader measure covering teacher pay and retention is publicly reported to be heading to voters on the November 2026 ballot; if approved, it would take effect in mid-2027. Florida's statewide cell phone ban, effective for the current school year, applies to all Lake County schools including this one, meaning students are not permitted to use phones during instructional time.
Chronic absenteeism and discipline data were not available in the materials provided, and no comparison to other Lake County district schools was possible given the structure of the comparison data. The full picture of what daily school life looks like here, including staffing levels and attendance patterns, remains incomplete from these sources alone.
See more original research from School Decision →