The top reported proficiency rate is 74% in Math. The lowest is 50% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Florine J Abel Elementary School
Florine J. Abel Elementary sits on Madonna Place in Sarasota's 34243 zip code, serving prekindergarten through fifth grade within the Manatee County school district. The school is a regular public elementary, not a charter or magnet, and its enrollment is typical for a school of its grade band in this part of Florida. A substantial majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting a community with real economic need. The student body is majority Hispanic, with meaningful shares of white and Black students and a smaller multiracial group. Data on English learner enrollment and students with individualized education programs were not available in the source data.
On Florida's FAST assessments, the picture is mixed and varies noticeably by grade. In math, third and fourth graders reached proficiency at rates that land below what a parent might hope for, while fifth graders performed considerably better, and the handful of sixth graders tested reached full proficiency. Parents of third and fourth graders who are watching for early math struggles may want to ask the school directly about what support structures are in place. ELA tells a softer story across all three tested grades: third grade proficiency was below half, and while fourth and fifth grade results improved incrementally, none of the ELA grades reached a majority of students at the proficient level. This is a pattern worth understanding in depth before enrolling, and a conversation with school staff about literacy intervention would be worthwhile. Fifth grade science came in just over half of students proficient. Trend data was not available, so it is not possible from this source to say whether results are improving, holding, or declining.
No program offerings data was available for Abel, and no information about course access, staffing ratios, attendance, or discipline was present in the source material. The comparison analysis found only one district in Manatee County, so no meaningful peer positioning was possible.
The broader Manatee County district context matters here. Voters renewed the district's one-mill property tax in late 2024, which publicly reported sources say continues to fund teacher salary supplements, an extended school day, STEM, arts, career and technical programs, early literacy, athletics, and school safety. That referendum funding is real and directly connected to what students experience day to day. The district also recently redrew elementary and middle school attendance zones in response to fast enrollment growth, which means families should confirm current zone assignments before making housing decisions. AI-based weapon detection systems have been installed at high schools and randomly at middle schools as a security measure following incidents in prior years.
The housing market near this school runs above the state median for home values and has seen modest year-over-year softening, both on the ownership and rental side. Rents in the zip code are substantial relative to typical incomes, and the rent-to-income ratio is elevated by most affordability benchmarks. Sarasota itself is in an active growth phase. New apartment supply has been coming online, and publicly reported data shows apartment vacancy in Sarasota County at a decade high as of early 2025, which may give renters some negotiating room. Master-planned communities in eastern Manatee County are driving much of the new residential development, and the district is building a new high school in Lakewood Ranch to open in 2027, which will eventually reshape high school attendance zones for families on that side of the district.
Sarasota as a city has a well-documented arts and cultural identity, bayfront public spaces, and walkable pockets in the downtown core and historic neighborhoods, though the area around Madonna Place is more car-dependent than the downtown districts. Health care and the school district itself are among the largest employers in the county, alongside manufacturing and tourism.
For a family considering Abel specifically, the academic proficiency data, particularly in ELA across all tested grades and in math in the early intermediate grades, suggests a school where support systems and what happens in the classroom for struggling readers and math learners should be central questions. The economic and demographic profile of the school points to a community where those questions are especially consequential.
See more original research from School Decision →