The top reported proficiency rate is 92% in Math. The lowest is 67% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Big Pine Academy
Big Pine Academy is a small charter school sitting at the southern end of the Florida Keys school landscape, serving children from pre-kindergarten through fifth grade on an island shaped as much by federal wildlife protection as by the Overseas Highway running through its middle. The school operates under the Monroe County School District's umbrella but as its own charter, giving families on Big Pine Key an alternative path before students eventually commute off-island for middle and high school.
The enrollment is quite small for even a PK-5 school, distributed thinly across grades, which gives the place an intimate feel that some families seek and others may find limiting in terms of peer variety or program breadth. The student body is predominantly white, with a meaningful Hispanic population and very small counts of other groups. About a quarter to a third of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, a share that sits noticeably below what you would see in many Florida elementary schools. Data on students with IEPs and English learners was not available in what we reviewed, so a parent with questions about special education services or language support would want to ask the school directly.
On state assessments, the picture is partial but worth understanding. Florida's FAST assessments are reported by grade, and for a school this small, the state suppresses results in grades where the tested group is too small to report without risking individual identification. Only third grade math and third grade ELA produced reportable numbers. The third grade math result was strong, well above what most Florida schools show. The third grade ELA result was more moderate, sitting in a range that a parent might want to explore further with the school. Fourth and fifth grade results across math, ELA, and science were all suppressed due to small group sizes, so they tell us nothing either way. Trend data was not available.
Because Monroe County has only one school district, the comparison framework that would normally place this school among county peers does not yield a useful ranking; there is simply no comparison set large enough to draw from.
The community surrounding the school is genuinely unusual. Big Pine Key is low-density, car-dependent, and hemmed in on all sides by the National Key Deer Refuge, which makes large-scale development legally impossible. What growth has occurred since Hurricane Irma came primarily through deed-restricted affordable housing projects built for workforce and low-income households, while market-rate property values have climbed to levels far above the Florida and national medians. For families buying into this market, housing costs are a substantial consideration, and the Monroe County School District adopted a property tax rate increase for 2025-26 directed at capital projects, which compounds the cost picture. On the positive side, voters in late 2024 renewed two longstanding local school funding referendums, publicly reported to support teacher salaries, school nurses, school resource officers, and facilities at every school in the district; those renewals carry forward an existing funding arrangement without a new tax burden.
Older children zoned to Big Pine Key attend Sugarloaf School on Summerland Key and then Marathon Middle High School in Marathon, both reachable only by driving the Overseas Highway. The Keys Overseas Heritage Trail runs along the highway and provides a biking route, but the daily reality for most families is car dependence. A public shuttle runs to Key West but takes close to an hour and a half, making it impractical for school transportation.
Big Pine Academy suits families drawn to a very small, charter-run elementary in a remote, nature-surrounded Keys community where the outdoors, wildlife, and tight-knit neighborhood life are central to daily experience. Families who want a larger peer group, richer extracurricular offerings at the elementary level, or readily available data on performance across all grades will find this school's profile thin in those areas and should visit and ask questions before enrolling.
See more original research from School Decision →