Original Research by School Decision on The College of the Florida Keys Academy
The College of the Florida Keys Academy is a small charter high school in Key West, serving students in grades nine through twelve. Its enrollment is quite small even by charter school standards, with a notable absence of twelfth graders in the reported data, which is unusual and worth asking the school about directly. The peer group is predominantly white, with smaller shares of Hispanic, Black, multiracial, and Asian students. A modest fraction of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which places this school well below the economic need levels seen in many Florida high schools.
Academic performance data was not available for this school. State assessment results and graduation rate data are both missing from what was reported, so there is no basis here to characterize how students perform on standardized measures or how many complete their diploma. The comparison set for Monroe County's districts shows those metrics as not applicable due to missing values, not because the school is exempt from them. A parent who wants to understand outcomes should ask the school directly for its state accountability ratings, graduation figures, and any available college enrollment data.
Program offerings were not reported in the available data, so it is not clear whether the school provides AP coursework, dual enrollment through its namesake College of the Florida Keys, career pathways, or other structured college-prep sequences. Given the school's affiliation by name with the community college, dual-enrollment access may be a meaningful feature worth exploring, but nothing in the data confirms that arrangement.
The school sits in Key West, which is the southernmost city in the continental United States. Key West is a small island city that draws millions of visitors annually, giving it a street life and built environment that blends heavily tourism-oriented commercial districts with year-round residential neighborhoods. The city is publicly reported as highly walkable and bikeable, particularly around the historic core, and the City of Key West runs several transit routes including a free Duval Loop, a north and south city route, and a Lower Keys Shuttle reaching as far as Marathon. On-demand transit within Key West and neighboring Stock Island launched in late 2023. The Monroe County May Hill Russell Library, among the oldest in Florida, serves the community and houses a regional history collection.
Housing costs here are among the highest in the state. Home values in the relevant zip code run dramatically above the Florida state median and well above national norms, and rents follow a similar pattern. Both have shifted modestly in recent months, with home values slightly down year over year and rents edging up. For a family relocating, the gap between local housing costs and a typical income is substantial, and the rent-to-income burden is well above what financial planners generally consider manageable. This is simply the reality of the Keys housing market, not a condition unique to this school's zone.
At the district level, Monroe County voters in November 2024 renewed two longstanding school funding measures: one tied to operations such as teacher pay, school nurses, and school resource officers, and one tied to capital projects and facilities. Both passed as continuations of existing levies. Separately, the district adopted a property tax rate increase for the 2025-26 fiscal year, directing additional capital outlay funds toward construction, safety upgrades, ADA compliance, renovations, and buses. Families purchasing homes in Key West would absorb this as part of their annual school tax obligation.
Because so much of this school's academic data is absent, including test results, graduation outcomes, chronic absenteeism, staffing ratios, discipline data, and program specifics, a family evaluating it is working with an incomplete picture. The school's small size may appeal to families who want a tight-knit environment, but the academic track record and program depth are questions that require a direct conversation with school leadership.
See more original research from School Decision →