The top reported proficiency rate is 62% in Math. The lowest is 53% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Castle Creek Elementary
Castle Creek Elementary sits on North Avalon Park Boulevard in East Orlando, a predominantly suburban corridor that feels distinctly different from the tourist-heavy southwest or the urban downtown core. The neighborhood reflects a working and middle-class residential character, and the school serves pre-kindergarten through fifth grade as a regular public elementary within Orange County Public Schools.
The school's enrollment is mid-sized for an elementary school. A majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which places this in the range of schools with meaningful concentrations of economic need. The student population is predominantly Hispanic, with Black and white students each making up smaller but present shares, and a modest Asian population. Data on English learner rates and students with IEPs was not available in what we reviewed.
On state assessments, the picture varies by grade and subject. In math, third graders performed solidly, with most students reaching proficiency, a genuinely encouraging result at that foundational grade. Proficiency drops in the middle elementary years and partially recovers by fifth grade, suggesting some unevenness across the grade band that a parent may want to ask the school about directly. In reading and language arts, scores are more consistently in the range where roughly half of students or fewer reach proficiency across the tested grades, which is below where most families would hope to see their child's school land. Fifth-grade science proficiency comes in a bit better than ELA, with the majority of tested students reaching that bar. Placed against districts in Orange County, the school's overall proficiency index sits above the midpoint of the comparison set, which is worth acknowledging, though the county comparison set here is small and that position should be read with some caution.
Multi-year trend data was not available, so it is not possible to say whether these results represent improvement, stability, or decline over time.
No program offerings data was provided, so specific enrichment, gifted, intervention, or extracurricular programs cannot be described here. Parents interested in those supports would do well to contact the school directly or review the district's program directory.
The housing market around the zip code is priced above the Florida statewide median and well above the national median. Home values have edged slightly downward year over year, and rents are effectively flat. The estimated monthly carrying cost of a home at current values and mortgage rates is substantial relative to typical household incomes, a real consideration for families weighing the area. Renting runs close to buying on a monthly basis. East Orlando broadly has continued to attract residential growth, and the Avalon Park area itself was developed specifically as a planned community with walkable village centers, which is publicly noted as one of the more pedestrianly approachable suburban pockets in East Orlando.
Orlando as a city is undergoing sustained development, with major employment anchored by tourism, healthcare, the University of Central Florida, and aerospace and defense. East Orlando is closer to the UCF corridor than to the downtown or tourist zones, giving the surrounding community a somewhat different character, tilted toward younger families, university workers, and suburban professionals.
The Orange County school district's strategic priorities and any recent changes specific to Castle Creek were not surfaced in research, so that layer of context is absent here.
For a family evaluating this school, the math performance at third grade is a genuine bright spot, and the school's position among Orange County districts is above the county midpoint. The ELA results in the upper elementary grades are weaker and worth a direct conversation with school leadership about what supports are in place for students who need to build reading fluency and comprehension. What the data cannot tell you is classroom culture, teacher stability, or the depth of intervention programs, all of which matter considerably at the elementary level and are worth pressing on during any school visit.
See more original research from School Decision →