The top reported proficiency rate is 53% in Science. The lowest is 29% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Spook Hill Elementary School
Spook Hill Elementary sits on Dr. J.A. Wiltshire Avenue in Lake Wales, a city in Polk County that is moving through an unusually active growth phase. The school serves prekindergarten through fifth grade as a regular public school within the Polk district. Its enrollment puts it at a mid-sized range for an elementary school of its grade band, and the student body is notably diverse: Hispanic students make up the largest share, followed by white students, then Black students, with smaller numbers of other backgrounds. The economic picture is stark. The vast majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, a figure that places the school well into high-poverty territory. Data on English learners and students with IEPs were not available in what was provided.
State assessment results from the most recent year show proficiency rates in reading and math that are meaningfully below state norms across every tested grade. In ELA, the fourth-grade figure is the lowest of the three tested grades and sits in the lower quarter of what Florida elementary schools typically report. Math scores follow a similar pattern, declining slightly from third grade to fifth. The one area where the school's results look comparatively stronger is fifth-grade science on the Florida Statewide Science Assessment, where roughly half of students scored proficient, a result that stands out against the literacy and math picture. Still, across ELA and math, a parent would reasonably want to ask the school directly about what supports are in place for students who are not yet reading or computing at grade level, and what interventions are available for children who enter needing to catch up.
Multi-year trend data were not available in what was provided, so it is not possible to characterize whether performance has been improving, declining, or holding steady. That context would be worth asking the school or Polk district to provide. A comparison against other Polk County districts was not computed because the county's district count falls below the threshold needed to produce a reliable position ranking.
The broader community offers relevant context. Lake Wales is a city organized around a compact historic core on the Lake Wales Ridge, shaped by an early Olmsted-era city plan whose residential streets were designed around palms, oaks, and magnolias. Publicly reported sources describe a downtown district currently working toward genuine pedestrian character, with streetscape reconstruction underway on several main corridors using a substantial federal RAISE grant. A Saturday farmers market, new dining spots, and murals have taken hold, though some downtown storefronts remain vacant. The dominant private employer is Florida's Natural Growers, a large citrus cooperative headquartered along US 27 that is among the largest of its kind in the country. Warner University and Bok Tower Gardens are also cited as local anchors.
The housing market around the school's zip code shows home values running well below both the Florida and national medians, with a modest year-over-year decline. Rents sit at a comparatively accessible level, and the rent-to-income ratio, measured against national median household income, falls in a reasonable range. For a family considering whether to buy near the school, the local price point is meaningfully lower than what most of Florida commands. Lake Wales is also in a pronounced growth cycle: publicly reported data show building permits rising sharply over the past several years, with a large number of new residential units approved across dozens of projects concentrated in the southern and eastern parts of the city, projecting a substantial population increase over coming years. Families settling here now should expect a changing neighborhood context.
Spook Hill Elementary is a high-poverty, racially diverse school in a community that is actively reinventing itself. Its academic results are below state norms in most subjects, and families with children who need literacy or math support would do well to engage closely with the school about what that support looks like in practice. The science result at fifth grade suggests the school is not uniformly flat, and that detail may be worth exploring further with staff.
See more original research from School Decision →