The top reported proficiency rate is 75% in Math. The lowest is 54% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Melrose Elementary School
Melrose Elementary sits on State Road 26 in the unincorporated rural community of Melrose, Florida, a small lakeside settlement in north-central Florida positioned between Gainesville and Palatka. The school serves pre-kindergarten through sixth grade, making it the only school most children in the area will attend until they leave for middle or high school. Understanding what this school offers means understanding both what the test results show and the substantial physical change coming to this campus in the near term.
On Florida's FAST assessments in the most recent school year, results are mixed across grades and subjects. Math proficiency is a relative strength in the upper elementary and sixth grade, with sixth graders performing especially well. Third and fifth grade math proficiency is more modest, sitting in the low-to-mid range. ELA tells a similar story of inconsistency: third and fourth grade ELA proficiency land in the low sixties, fifth grade dips below half, and sixth grade is considerably stronger at three-quarters proficiency. The fifth-grade Florida Statewide Science Assessment shows just over half of students reaching proficiency. Parents of children in the third-through-fifth grade range, particularly in ELA and science, may want to ask the school directly about its instructional approach and what supports are in place for students who are not yet reading or computing at grade level. Multi-year trend data was not available, so it is not possible to say whether these results represent improvement or decline.
A substantial share of the school's students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which places Melrose Elementary in an economically disadvantaged rural context that is typical of Putnam County. Data on special education rates and English learner enrollment were not available in the data provided. The school's racial composition is predominantly white, with smaller shares of students identifying as multiracial, Black, and Hispanic. The school is not a charter or magnet school.
The most consequential near-term development for any family considering this school is the district's publicly reported construction plan. A new campus is being built for Melrose Elementary as part of a voter-approved countywide school construction bond program. The existing building is part of a district that publicly reported holding Florida's second-oldest school facilities, and the replacement campus is expected to open within the next few school years. Families enrolling children now should ask the district directly about the projected transition timeline, which building students will occupy in the interim, and how attendance boundaries may shift. This is not a minor renovation; the current building will be replaced.
The bond program that funds this construction has raised property tax rates for Putnam County homeowners, and residents have publicly raised concerns about the tax burden. For families thinking about buying in the area, this is a real cost consideration on top of the housing market itself. Home values in the Melrose zip code are somewhat below both the Florida statewide median and the national median, and year-over-year appreciation has been modest and positive, which contrasts with a mild statewide decline. The rental market data was not available for this specific area. Purchasing near this school is relatively more accessible than in many Florida markets, though current mortgage rates make monthly carrying costs meaningful.
Melrose itself is a quiet, unincorporated rural community with a historic Victorian district listed on the National Register of Historic Places. State Road 26, one of Florida's oldest roads, runs through town as its main artery. The community is centered on access to Santa Fe Lake and Melrose Bay and is car-dependent; there is no meaningful public transit. Small businesses and restaurants operate in the historic core, but major employers in the immediate area were not identified in publicly available sources. The character is decidedly rural and unhurried, which suits families seeking distance from suburban density.
No information on specific program offerings, course access, staffing ratios, chronic absenteeism, or discipline data was available for Melrose Elementary. The graduation rate does not apply here given the school's grade band. What a parent can act on now is the test data across grades, the economic profile of the student body, and the fact that this school's physical future is actively being decided at the district level.
See more original research from School Decision →