The top reported proficiency rate is 70% in English language arts. The lowest is 52% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Indian Trails Middle School
Indian Trails Middle School sits on Tuskawilla Road in Winter Springs, a residential suburb of Orlando in Seminole County, serving sixth through eighth graders as a regular public school within Seminole County Public Schools.
The academic picture from Florida's most recent FAST assessments is mixed and worth examining grade by grade. In ELA, results are fairly steady across the three grades, with sixth graders reading at or near three-quarters proficient and seventh and eighth graders trailing only modestly. That is a reasonably strong showing for a middle school serving a diverse enrollment. Math tells a more uneven story. Seventh grade math proficiency is high, well above what you would expect from a typical Florida middle school, while sixth grade sits in the solid-but-not-standout range. Eighth grade math proficiency, though, drops sharply, landing well below the other two grades and below the school's own ELA floor. The reason for that gap is not explained in the data, and a parent whose child is entering or already in eighth grade math may want to ask the school directly about course sequencing, the shift to algebra-level content, and what support is available when students struggle. The eighth grade science result is solid, roughly in line with the school's ELA pattern. Multi-year trend data was not available for comparison.
The student body is sizable for a middle school. White students make up the largest share of enrollment, followed by Hispanic students, with smaller shares of Black, Asian, and multiracial students. Close to half the student body qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch, meaning economic diversity is a real feature of the school's daily environment. Data on students with IEPs and English learners was not reported in what we received, so families with children in those populations would want to ask the school directly.
Publicly reported district policy context matters here. For the 2025-26 school year, Seminole County Public Schools banned cell phones for middle schoolers throughout the entire school day, not just during instruction. That is a meaningful shift in the daily environment. The district also formally classifies AI-assisted work as plagiarism, beginning the prior school year, raising the bar on academic integrity expectations. Both policies shape what the classroom culture looks like day to day. On the funding side, Seminole County voters renewed a penny sales tax supporting school infrastructure and security, and the district approved a modest budget of roughly a billion and a half dollars for 2025-26, meaning facilities investment continues.
Winter Springs itself is a car-dependent suburb, established and family-oriented, roughly a 15-mile drive north of downtown Orlando. The housing market around Indian Trails is priced above the Florida statewide median, and rents have been ticking upward recently even as home values dipped slightly year over year. Mortgage costs relative to income sit at a stretch for many buyers at current rates, and the rent-to-income ratio is moderately demanding. For families weighing a move specifically for this school, the housing context means the neighborhood is an investment in a higher-cost, stable suburban market rather than an entry-level one.
The Cross Seminole Trail, a long paved multi-use path, runs through the city and passes near the school's general corridor, providing outdoor recreational access. Central Winds Park on Lake Jesup is the city's main civic gathering space. Commercial life clusters around the Town Center, and the city is adding density through new townhome projects, drawing some local concern about growth pace.
A peer-comparison profile against other districts in Seminole County was not available because Seminole has only one public district, so no meaningful local benchmark exists in the data we have.
The school's own website is a reasonable next step for any family wanting specifics on elective offerings, clubs, counseling, and what the eighth grade math pathway actually looks like before and after that proficiency dip.
See more original research from School Decision →