The top reported proficiency rate is 77% in Science. The lowest is 71% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Geneva Elementary School
Geneva Elementary sits on First Street in one of the quietest corners of Seminole County, a small unincorporated rural community where large wooded lots, scattered farmland, and proximity to the St. Johns River floodplain define daily life far more than any commercial strip. Publicly reported sources describe the community as rooted in 19th-century farming and timber traditions, with the school itself built around an old brick schoolhouse that now functions as a local heritage center nearby. The nearest library branch, shopping, and secondary schools are a drive away in Oviedo, Sanford, or Lake Mary, and Seminole County's voter-protected rural boundary keeps the area at very low density with no large subdivisions expected. Most new housing here takes the form of custom homes on substantial parcels. Families considering a move should know that home values in this zip code sit meaningfully above both the Florida state median and the national median, and have held relatively flat year over year, so the entry cost is real even as prices have stabilized.
The school serves pre-kindergarten through fifth grade as a regular public school within Seminole County Public Schools. Enrollment is moderate for an elementary of this grade band and setting. Close to half of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, so the school serves a genuinely mixed economic range, even within a community that skews toward homeownership. The student body is predominantly white, with Hispanic students making up the next largest group and smaller numbers of students from other backgrounds. Data on students with IEPs and English learners was not available in the data provided, so a parent with those questions should contact the school directly.
On Florida's FAST assessments for the most recent reported year, third-grade math results are a clear strength, with the vast majority of students scoring proficient. Fifth-grade science also shows strong performance, with more than three-quarters of students reaching proficiency. ELA results across third, fourth, and fifth grades fall in the upper-middle range, with third grade leading and fourth and fifth grades a bit lower but still solid relative to typical Florida elementary baselines. Fourth- and fifth-grade math proficiency rates are noticeably lower than third grade, sitting roughly in the upper-half range rather than the high-end range the third-grade cohort reached. The sixth-grade math figure shows complete proficiency, but that likely reflects a very small number of students in that tested group and should be read cautiously. A parent who wants to understand the fourth- and fifth-grade math trajectory in more detail would do well to ask the school what supplemental supports are in place. Multi-year trend data was not available, so it is not possible to say whether these patterns are improving or stable.
No program offerings were reported in the data, so specifics about enrichment, gifted services, or intervention programs are a gap here. The school is not a magnet and carries no charter status. A graduation rate does not apply, as the school serves only elementary grades.
At the district level, Seminole County Public Schools made a notable policy change for the current school year, prohibiting cell phone use for elementary students throughout the entire school day. For families who want that kind of structured, distraction-limited environment, this matters. The district also now treats AI-generated work as plagiarism, which shapes expectations even in upper elementary grades as students begin research and writing projects. On the funding side, county voters renewed a one-cent infrastructure sales surtax in late 2024, which publicly reported sources indicate supports school improvements, security upgrades, and classroom technology across the district. The school property tax millage rate has edged down slightly in recent years, though rising property values mean most homeowners are paying a higher total school tax bill than before.
For a family drawn to a rural, low-density community with a strong sense of place, a relatively intimate school setting, and solid core academic results in most tested areas, Geneva Elementary fits that picture well. The fourth- and fifth-grade math numbers are worth a direct conversation with the school.
See more original research from School Decision →