The top reported proficiency rate is 64% in Social studies. The lowest is 18% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Mclendon Elementary School
McLendon Elementary serves the heart of Decatur as a small, densely enrolled neighborhood school in a walkable, progressive urban setting. The school is located in a downtown-adjacent area anchored by the DeKalb County courthouse, independent shops and restaurants, parks, and MARTA transit—a built environment where many families live on foot and within a few blocks of schools, work, and civic life. The city itself has been through consistent residential infill for two decades, with apartments, townhouses, and condominiums filling in near downtown. Housing values in the Decatur zip code are notably higher than state and national benchmarks, and rents are correspondingly elevated, making this a neighborhood that typically draws families with higher incomes or established roots; affordability has been a citywide conversation, though recent developments like Village at Legacy have added ground-up affordable housing for the first time in decades.
The school's enrollment is small and economically concentrated: nearly all students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, a strong indicator of economic hardship and a reminder that despite the surrounding area's overall affluence, McLendon serves a community within Decatur where poverty is the norm. The student body is predominantly Black, with meaningful shares of Hispanic, Asian, and mixed-race students; white enrollment is very small. This composition reflects both Decatur's own demographics and the fact that McLendon's catchment likely includes lower-income neighborhoods alongside wealthier blocks.
Academic proficiency across tested grades is low. In the most recent state assessments, fewer than a quarter of third and fourth graders scored at proficiency in math or reading, and even in fifth grade—where results are somewhat stronger—reading proficiency hovered around a quarter and math closer to a third. Science proficiency in fifth grade was similarly modest. These are not numbers that reflect strong foundational skill-building, and a parent considering this school should ask directly what academic interventions or supports are in place for struggling readers and mathematicians in the early grades, where such skills anchor everything that follows. The school does not yet have sufficient multi-year data to show whether these results represent a dip, a plateau, or a longer pattern, so recent history and current initiatives would be worth exploring with school leadership. Georgia shifted its assessment in the most recent year, and trend comparability is unclear, but the baseline is nonetheless sobering.
No information was available on the school's discipline record, chronic absenteeism, staffing, special education services, English learner supports, or specific academic programs. These gaps matter, because they would help explain both the low proficiency and what the school is doing to address it. A parent evaluating McLendon should ask the school directly about intervention programs, tutoring, reading specialists, and how the school identifies and supports students who fall behind early.
The school sits within DeKalb County, a large urban district in transition. The district is currently undertaking a major Student Assignment Project that could close or repurpose dozens of schools over the next several years to address significant enrollment surplus. This is a direct, lasting consideration: any family moving to Decatur should understand that their child's attendance boundary and school assignment may shift materially in the near term. Additionally, DeKalb faces a decades-old property-tax structure that has been gradually rolled back but remains one of the highest in the state, and millage reductions have been offset by rising home values, so property taxes on Decatur homes continue to climb. The district is executing significant capital projects funded by a recent sales-tax referendum, including new schools and career-track academies, which will reshape secondary options over time.
Decatur itself is a small, walkable city with strong civic anchors, an active downtown, and substantial infrastructure investment underway. Legacy Park, a new 77-acre greenspace, has become a gathering point. The housing market is robust and appreciating, and the city draws families seeking walkability, progressive values, and proximity to Atlanta's employment centers. For families comfortable with an economically concentrated school serving high-poverty students, McLendon offers a neighborhood school in a genuinely pedestrian-friendly setting. For families prioritizing strong early literacy and numeracy outcomes, the proficiency data should prompt careful conversation with school staff about what has driven these results and what is actively being done to lift them.
See more original research from School Decision →