The top reported proficiency rate is 90% in Social studies. The lowest is 38% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Tolbert Elementary School
Tolbert Elementary School serves pre-kindergarten through fifth grade in Resaca, a small north Georgia town along the Oostanaula River in Gordon County. The school enrolls students from a largely blue-collar community where most residents work in production, manufacturing, and service occupations. The student body is predominantly white, with a substantial Hispanic population and smaller numbers of students from other backgrounds. Nearly all students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting the economic conditions of the families the school serves.
On recent state assessments, Tolbert's proficiency rates sit below the midpoint among Gordon County's districts. In third grade, students showed proficiency rates around that of early elementary achievement—roughly matching proficiency across math and language arts. Fourth and fifth grade results improved slightly in math but remained modest overall. Fifth-grade science proficiency was in the mid-range, while language arts proficiency across grades three through five stayed relatively flat. An older social studies assessment from 2013 showed much stronger performance, though that measure is no longer in use. Overall proficiency across tested subjects and grades places this school in the top quartile within Gordon County, a finding that reflects the composition of that specific comparison group rather than a broad strength.
The school's population is small and tight-knit, with roughly mid-sized enrollment for an elementary school and nearly all grades represented. The youngest students, in pre-K and kindergarten, account for a meaningful share of the building. No data on the rate of students with disabilities or English learners was available.
Resaca itself is a very small town with no public transit and an auto-oriented built environment split by Interstate 75. Most families drive to nearby Calhoun, Dalton, or Rome for employment and services. Median home value in the area is substantially below the state average, and the housing market remains affordable. The town has grown only modestly over the past decade, with new residential construction happening in the surrounding county rather than in a compact center. Historic sites, including the Resaca Battlefield and Confederate Cemetery, anchor civic life, though daily activity depends on driving to larger nearby towns.
Gordon County Schools operates under a stable financial footing. Voters renewed the local one-cent education sales tax in 2021, extending it through 2027 and funding facility renovations and technology upgrades without raising property taxes at that moment. However, property values have risen through reassessment, so even as the millage rate has been held flat, school tax bills are climbing. Georgia's newly approved homestead exemption, effective January 2025, caps annual valuation growth for owner-occupied homes to the inflation rate, a change that will affect how school taxes are calculated going forward for families in the district.
A parent considering Tolbert should expect a small, economically challenged community school where proficiency rates are moderate and will require close attention to how the child progresses in reading and math. The school sits in a town with limited walkability and employment diversity, so families need reliable transportation and work options in the broader region. The affordability of housing and the stability of school funding through the sales tax extension are practical strengths for families with tighter budgets. Parents may want to visit the school and ask directly about reading interventions, math support, and how the school works with families whose home language is not English.
See more original research from School Decision →